Here Is Something To Cause Worry For Browns’ Fans

It was reported late last week that the driving force for the changes in the Cleveland Browns’ coaching staff, particularly offensive coordinator Alex Van Pelt, came from on top, meaning owners Jimmy and Dee Haslam, and chief strategy office Paul DePodesta.

Of all the things Browns’ fans worry about, and believe us, there are many, this should be the one most concerning.

We realize that NFL owners are very successful people or come from very successful families, but that doesn’t mean they understand football.

Of course, that’s what DePodesta is for, right?

We get there is frustration and nervousness from the top of the organization over the failure of their huge investment, Deshaun Watson to make an impact over his first two years with the Browns.

Our belief is that those two were the driving force behind making the deal. And that’s not assigning blame. We felt Watson was one of the top five quarterbacks in the league in his last season in Houston, and if you can get someone that good at that position, you have to give it a shot.

However, we aren’t sure the problem with Watson was the offensive coaching staff. It’s more about his availability, he’s only played 11 of the 34 games he has been on the roster due to suspension or injury. Van Pelt and coach Kevin Stefanski didn’t create that situation.

On the other hand, in only three of those 11 contests has Watson had a passer rating of over 100. In 2022, it was attributed to rust. Last season? He seemed to turn a corner in week three vs. the Titans but was injured in that game on a designed run.

His next complete games were against Arizona where he had a 107.5 passer rating, followed by the win over the Ravens in which he was tremendous in the second half, but also suffered a season ending injury.

To be fair, teams change coordinators all the time and as we wrote a little over a week ago, a new voice, a different perspective isn’t necessarily bad. Maybe new coordinator Ken Dorsey can bring some new elements to make Watson more like the player he was in Houston.

On the other hand, Watson will be 29 when the 2024 season starts, and perhaps Dorsey should be more judicious in how many designed runs are called for him. After all, Cleveland has a lot invested in him and needs him to be on the field.

The pressure from the top though is certainly concerning. Powerful people own NFL teams and they have large egos. Our theory about no one hiring Bill Belichick for 2024 is that some of these owners would rather have control and lose than give up some of that control and win.

That doesn’t mean Belichick is perfect, but he has proven to be a very good football coach, and if he has talent he will win. We think coaching means more in football than in any other sport. Look at what Jim Schwartz did with the Browns’ defense in 2023.

Maybe Belichick doesn’t deserve control of picking the players anymore, but he should be able to have a comfort level with the person who does.

We have to think the only reason he isn’t coaching is because an owner wants his hands on the operation.

And to that, we come back to the old saying: A wise man knows what he doesn’t know.

Sometimes Change And/Or Considering It, Is Good In Sports

Earlier this week, the Cleveland Browns made news when coach Kevin Stefanski announced he let go three members of his offensive coaching staff: Offensive coordinator/quarterbacks coach Alex Van Pelt, running backs coach Stump Mitchell, and TE coach T.C. McCartney.

Browns’ fans, being among the most rational people on earth, had plenty to say, mostly because it is how things have been in Berea for most of the expansion era, they felt it was a sign of disarray in the hierarchy.

And of course, some blamed Paul DePodesta, because since he rarely appears or speaks to the media, he has because something like the Wizard of Oz.

First, we would think if Stefanski and the organization let these coaches go, they probably have a pretty good idea of who they are going after to replace them. We have always said, anyone is replaceable if you go and get someone better.

Second, it isn’t necessarily a bad thing to keep bringing different voices into a group, coaching staff, or a sports organization. Diverse opinions should not only be tolerated but embraced. Of course, within reason.

Like if someone keeps telling you Yu Chang is a potential Hall of Fame baseball player, you might want to check credentials.

All three coaches have been here since Stefanski was named head coach four years ago, and coaches are no different than anyone else, they get stuck in their ways, not completely open to new ideas. We are sure everyone works with people like that.

And the Browns didn’t win the Super Bowl, so there is definitely room for improvement in all aspects of the team. We think Stefanski had to be encouraged to make some changes to his staff last season, when he let go of Joe Woods and Mike Priefer. Perhaps he saw how that worked out and these changes might have the same benefit.

Among the other teams in town, we would love for the Guardians to have some different ideas in their organization. At times, they have weird attachments to players, and maybe having a new manager solves some of that.

We think Terry Francona was a great manager, but often said his weakness was the fine line between patience and stubbornness.

We would love to be in an organizational meeting for the Guards, just to hear if anyone says, “Myles Straw is one of the worst hitters in baseball” or “Yes, Gabriel Arias hits the ball hard, but he rarely hits it”.

For the Cavs, we would like to know the reasoning for ignoring height in a sport where most of the great players in the game had size advantages (think LeBron: if you are as quick, you aren’t as big, and vice-versa), or what everyone sees in Dean Wade.

We think the worst thing that can occur is when everyone is on the same page, and no one thinks outside the box. And again, that doesn’t mean arguing about something everyday. Just being able to see things from a different “perspective”.

That might be exactly what happened in Berea this week. This isn’t the same dysfunctional organization that we came to know from 1999 to when the complete rebuild started about 10 years ago.

It’s just a sign that they want to take the next step in their goal of winning a title.

Browns Still Have Faith In Watson. Without A Doubt.

Even though the Cleveland Browns had a pretty good free agent signing period, most pundits still don’t seem to think that highly of Kevin Stefanski’s squad, thinking they are still not a playoff team.

Most of that comes from the lack of faith in QB Deshaun Watson, who didn’t exactly light up the league when he returned from suspension for the last six games of the 2022 season.

After all, Cleveland went just 3-3 in the games Watson piloted the team, and his best passer rating in the half dozen starts was in the win over the Commanders, and he was only 9 for 18 in that game, but threw three touchdown passes with no interceptions.

The football press seems to have lost confidence in Watson, despite his last complete season in which he threw for a league-leading 4823 yards, and had 33 TD tosses and just seven picks. The Texans went 4-12 that year, allowing the sixth most points in the NFL.

Some folks in the local media have extrapolated that lack of faith from the national media and attribute it to the Browns’ front office, after all, what did Watson do in those last six games to make anyone think he can lead Cleveland to the postseason in 2023?

Don’t buy into that.

First, when the Browns decided to move off of Baker Mayfield following the 2021 campaign and go after Watson, they didn’t do it based on a whim or irritation that Mayfield had problems with some teammates and perhaps didn’t see eye to eye with Stefanski.

They did it because one of the league’s best quarterbacks, which Watson was at the time, was available and the Browns’ thinkers saw it as an opportunity to get a great QB in his prime, after all Watson will be just 28 years old when the season begins.

Really, what do you think is more indicative of Watson’s abilities, the three year period from 2018-20, when he led the Texans to two playoff appearances, including a wild card win over Buffalo, and followed that up with his individual excellence in ’21, or the last six games of last year, following a year and a half layoff?

The Browns’ front office, GM Andrew Berry, Paul DePodesta, and Stefanski did their due diligence, studied Watson’s time in Houston and we are sure it was discussed that it might be a long, long time before a QB as good as Watson, and in their prime would come available.

So, they went all in.

The Browns get charged with being dysfunctional all the time, particularly when they lose a game, but to us, being dysfunctional involves making knee-jerk decisions based on emotion. Losing faith in Watson after those half-dozen games at the end of last season would fit that profile.

They know what they traded for and they saw Watson in practice, meaning they’ve seen him more than anyone else. We are sure they still think they made the correct decision on giving up a lot of future assets for a player they believe can solve their quarterback problem for years to come.

And let’s face it, if they are wrong about the former Clemson quarterback, they made a colossal mistake, one that will take them years to recover from.

When you make a move like this, there is no going back, and that’s why the Browns went hard in free agency. They know the time to win is right now. We are sure they are confident that Deshaun Watson is the man to take them to the Super Bowl.

Losing faith on this would be a sign this leadership group is doomed.

Browns Seem To Lack Accountability, Toughness.

Let’s say this right off the top. We don’t want Kevin Stefanski fired.

We get that’s the knee-jerk reaction from fans every time the Cleveland Browns lose a football game, particularly when it is a blowout loss, like Sunday’s 39-17 beatdown by the Miami Dolphins, but many times it just the easy way out.

If the Browns are indeed run primarily by Paul DePodesta, GM Andrew Berry, and Stefanski, and we are sure they meet all the time, they should be “self-auditing” as to how they lead this organization going forward.

This isn’t to say the defense isn’t the biggest problem on this football team. You simply cannot win at any level if you can’t stop the run and the Browns can’t do it.

However, Stefanski isn’t a Dan Campbell or Mike Vrabel type of coach or leader. He’s not out of the Hollywood prototype of what a head football coach should be. However, everyone needs to remember he did play at the college level.

Stefanski’s style might be fine if he had players who were vocal leaders, but it doesn’t seem he does. His best offensive player, Nick Chubb, leads by example. The player who talks the most is a guard, Joel Bitonio. On defense, Myles Garrett is accessible, but most talks in cliches.

Now, we don’t know what happens in the locker room (and by the way, neither do many of the folks commenting on the Browns in the media).

Some people have said the Browns have no identity, and we think it could be because they seem to be very reactive.

The Browns should be a running team, particularly with Jacoby Brissett at quarterback. But if the other team put eight or nine in the box, Cleveland throws it, and throws it some more.

We would love it if Stefanski called plays with the confidence of you know what, we are going to run it anyway. For Nick Chubb to get just 11 carries (as he did Sunday) in a game where he is healthy for all four quarters is unacceptable.

At times we think if Stefanski were coaching the Kansas City Chiefs, he would think to himself, the other team knows Patrick Mahomes is going to throw, so we have to run it a lot.

Andy Reid doesn’t think that way. No head coach should.

Same on defense. Our thought during the Dolphins game was if you know the opponent has great talent and you are just going to line up and rush four and play zone coverage, you are going to get beat. You need to do something that gets the Miami offense out of rhythm.

We can’t remember many plays, if there were any, where the Browns sent more than four rushers at Tua Tagovailoa. We also can’t recall Myles Garrett being moved around as to where he lined up. It doesn’t seem give the defense the best chance to succeed.

We wrote after the Bengals game that we learned the Browns were capable of playing that way defensively, so the expectations were increased. But maybe the defensive coordinator felt increased job security, so he reverted to what had been done in the past. It didn’t work then, and it didn’t work Sunday.

It seems like the organization lives in fear at times. Can’t admit mistakes on draft picks (they’ve cut just one in the Berry regime), can’t attack defensively because they might give up a big play, can’t stick with the strength of the team’s offense.

There can be a thing as being too smart for your own good. Maybe the Browns are stuck in that, and they need to remember this is football, a tough physical sport.

In the end, it’s another loss year for the fans, still waiting for a Super Bowl berth.

Browns Moving On At QB Wasn’t A Rash Decision

We have said from the very end of the Browns’ season in 2021 that Andrew Berry, Paul DePodesta, and Kevin Stefanski would evaluate every position on the football field in an effort to improve the team for 2022.

There were no leaks and crazy speculation from inside Berea, but in appears the trio do hold Baker Mayfield responsible for the offensive issues and are preparing to move on from the former first overall pick.

We do not doubt for a second that there was some turmoil between the quarterback and the head coach last season. Mayfield criticized the offensive game plan, and when you do that publicly, you are butting heads with the guy calling the plays.

Let’s clear a couple of things up first. We have heard that Mayfield only played well here for a small stretch of games, those being the second half of the 2020 season, when the Browns made the playoffs. That’s not true.

Mayfield was very good his rookie season. Remember Cleveland went 0-16 the year before he arrived, and they did go 6-7 in his 13 starts. And he had career highs in completion percentage and touchdown passes.

And the Browns were 2-2 the next season after a resounding 40-25 win at Baltimore. Mayfield was 20 of 30 for 342 yards in that contest.

What followed was a four game losing streak, started with a pair of multi-interception games vs. San Francisco and Seattle. The Browns finished 6-10 and Freddie Kitchens lost his job.

Secondly, remember that the coach and front office inherited Mayfield. They didn’t draft him and therefore didn’t have any attachment. They tried to make things work out, but apparently felt he was more of a problem than a solution going forward.

There can be no doubt Mayfield was not 100% after the Houston game in week two, but we felt (and still do) that the organization kept him in the lineup more because they had no confidence i Case Keenum handling the position, and our guess is Keenum won’t be with the team much longer either.

Another thing to consider is Mayfield’s psyche. It seemed toward the end of the season that he developed the “yips”, meaning it appeared he was afraid to pull the trigger at times. If that happened, the Browns may have no choice. They don’t have the time to rebuild his confidence.

There is no question Deshaun Watson is a top five quarterback in the sport and getting him would improve the position for the Browns. However, you have to figure the price tag to get him (a lot of draft capital) and the current situation in his personal life.

There are many fans who will have a problem getting Watson, and although they will continue to root for the Browns, it will feel a little slimy to support the QB.

And remember, Watson can approve where he goes (ironic right?), so what if he decides he doesn’t want to play in Cleveland? Where do the Browns go for their new signal caller?

First, we don’t think for a minute that the organization put all their eggs in the Watson basket. They have been studying options since the minutes the gun sounded in their week 18 win over the Bengals.

We would guess they are looking at making a deal for Jimmy Garoppolo or Matt Ryan, and perhaps also looking at Jameis Winston.

We also think if they don’t get Watson, thus keeping the 13th overall pick, they will not be taking a quarterback there. If they think the quarterback position is holding them back, they aren’t going to play a rookie there in 2022. Drafting a developmental guy there instead of a player who can help right away doesn’t make sense either.

We should know soon how everything will play out. But it’s pretty clear the Cleveland Browns will have a new starting quarterback next season. Berry and Stefanski probably knew that a while ago.

Football 2021 Is Over, Browns Look Towards ’22

The Super Bowl is over and thankfully, a team from the AFC North did not win. Although the new league year doesn’t arrive until March 16th, the off-season has arrived and everyone should be turning their attention to the 2022 season.

First, the Cleveland Browns are not a terrible football team, in the same class as Jacksonville, Houston, etc. They didn’t go 4-13 or 5-12 during the 2021 season, they went 8-9, and with a little luck, they would have made the playoffs.

Still, having good luck isn’t a strategy any more than hope is. And there is no doubt you are what you record says you are, and the Browns were a below .500 football team.

The first challenge Andrew Berry, Paul DePodesta, and Kevin Stefanski have to do is get the roster united and cohesive. There was a little bit too much happiness for Odell Beckham Jr. being a Super Bowl champion among the current players.

On the other hand, there is a difference between being a good friend and a good guy and being someone the coaching staff can trust. Being cool among players is one thing, but for coaches and front office types, a player can be a different story.

Perhaps Beckham challenged Stefanski’s authority or complained every week about the style of football the coaches wanted to play. Maybe that’s why the wide receiver wasn’t “a good fit” here.

We aren’t going to rehash the quarterback situation again, but we will say this–the passing game as a whole has to be better. The wide receiver and tight end positions need to be addressed and improved. They need more separation, or in old school terminology, the Browns need receivers who can get open.

We would also like to see Stefanski use Nick Chubb and Kareem Hunt together. They are two of the best players the team has, and using just one at a time seems foolish. Make opposing defenses account for both, and that brings us to another question.

Why not get Chubb more involved in the passing game? We understand it is a good way to keep the Pro Bowl back fresh, taking him off the field in passing situations, but the defense knows this as well.

And having Chubb catch a short pass in the secondary where he doesn’t have to contend with defensive linemen should be a benefit, no? It doesn’t seem like he has bad hands, so why not incorporate this into the offense?

These playoffs should also show the front office the importance of having a reliable field goal kicker.

In the AFC North alone resides the most accurate kicker in the Ravens’ Justin Tucker (94.6%) and the 10th ranked, Pittsburgh’s Chris Boswell (90%). Cincinnati’s rookie Evan McPherson didn’t miss a field goal in the playoffs, making two game winners.

Chase McLaughlin? He ranked 32nd in the league at 71.4%. Having a reliable field goal kicker changes how you coach and manage the game.

It doesn’t matter if it is through the draft or a free agent, the Browns have to get a more reliable field goal kicker, someone they feel comfortable with from 50 yards and in. They’ve been without one since Phil Dawson left.

When you are 8-9 and the division winner finished at 10-7, you better believe the little things, including having a solid kicker, make a big difference.

Browns’ Dysfunction? We Don’t See It.

A lot of things have been said about the Cleveland Browns after they missed the playoffs this season with an 8-9 record, but to us, the weirdest thing is saying the dysfunction that was a trademark of much of the last 20 years, has returned to Berea.

Quite frankly, we don’t see any evidence of it.

Most of the noise surrounding the Browns have come from the media, the front office has been largely silent.

It’s the media and fans who are saying the team is deficient at the quarterback position and coming up with crazy scenarios to get some of the best QBs in the game in a Cleveland uniform.

And apparently at least one media member believes Andrew Berry and Kevin Stefanski should have anticipated a wide receiver coming off a season ending knee injury would ask out of town and when he didn’t get his wish, would put less than a sterling effort on the field.

We are sure the organization thought the player would be excited to come back to a playoff team, and try to help it toward the next level or two of the post-season.

What the Browns should be doing right now is a self audit, looking at what went wrong AND also what went right in an effort to be better next season. And with Berry, Paul DePodesta, and Stefanski handling this, we are sure it is being done without emotion.

By the way, that’s the correct approach, despite what the fans and media want.

To us, the dysfunction would be if we heard rumors that ownership was unhappy with the hierarchy in the organization or Stefanski’s job was in jeopardy because he didn’t follow up a post-season appearance with another one.

Instead, things are relatively quiet.

In fact, the Minnesota Vikings hired Kwesi Adofo-Mensah, the vice president for football operations with the Browns, as their new general manager. And Adofo-Mensah went out of his way at his introductory press conference to call Berry a “rock star” and thank him for what he learned in Cleveland.

Sounds like it’s a crazy atmosphere in Berea, no?

We have said this before, we are sure the front office is doing everything it can to improve this football team so the absence from the post-season ends at one season. And they are looking at every position for improvement, including quarterback.

The dysfunctional thing to do would be to act with emotion, make a knee-jerk reaction to a season that fell short of expectations, and start making wholesale changes as soon as the season ended.

We didn’t see any of that. The only move made was a special teams assistant coach was let go. Defensive line coach Chris Kiffin left to join his brother’s staff at Ole Miss, but we would believe that has more to do with working with his brother than a bad atmosphere in the organization.

As for Odell Beckham Jr., the organization did right by him. They could have told him to go home and stay there when his unhappiness reached a crescendo, but they worked out a settlement so he could play somewhere else.

So people are finding fault with that as well.

What we don’t see is conflicts between the head coach and the front office, or between the owner and the front office.

We guess after this season, dysfunction is defined as not going crazy and firing or cutting coaches and players.

The narrative for some keeps changing…

Where Browns Need To Get Better (Non-QB Categories)

Believe it or not, and based on the conversation in northeast Ohio over the past couple of weeks, the latter seems to be what fans think, there is more wrong with the Cleveland Browns than Kevin Stefanski’s play calling or Baker Mayfield’s ability to play his position.

We know, hard to believe, right?

But here are other things GM Andrew Berry and Paul DePodesta need to address before training camp starts in late July.

We understand the offensive tackle spots were ravaged by injuries from the opening game of the season, when Jedrick Wills hurt his ankle, but Cleveland needs better play next season out of the position.

We are confident in Wills, who just finished his second season in the NFL. Losing some of his mobility because of the ankle hampered his performance to be sure. And as for RT Jack Conklin, you can make a strong case the Browns’ running game took a big hit when he was basically lost for the year in the Chargers’ game.

The Browns averaged 187.6 yards on the ground through their visit to Los Angeles, and that figure dropped to a still respectable 154.5 the remainder of the season. That includes six games they were held under 100.

Primary reserve Chris Hubbard was also hurt early in the season, so the brown and orange were down to the 4th tackle on the depth chart most of the time. If rookie James Hudson improves and can take Hubbard’s (he’s a free agent) role. That would be a big help.

The team also needs an improvement in the receiving corps.

Jarvis Landry’s 52 receptions led the team and no other wide receiver caught more than Donovan Peoples-Jones’ 34. And the latter led the squad in receiving yards with a paltry 597.

We understand the Browns use a tight end heavy offense, but they didn’t stand out either, with Austin Hooper catching 38 balls and David Njoku right behind him with 36 receptions.

Without question, the passing game missed Kareem Hunt, who led running backs with just 22 catches. We understand WR Anthony Schwartz should get better as well as his fellow rookie Demetric Felton, but it looks here like several players will need to be added to shore up this unit.

Although the defense got better as the year went along, in the last 11 contests, the Browns allowed more than 20 points just four times, there was an area the team could improve, and that is in stopping the run.

Over the last eight games, the defense allowed 137 yards per contest on the ground. If they could control the ground game better, imagine how good the defense would have been?

And maybe, with more long yardage situations, they would have more opportunities to really dial up some pressure on quarterbacks via the blitz.

Cleveland has very good cornerbacks and the safeties got better and better as the season went on. But if it easy to gain a good chunk of yards on first down, the offense has more options in terms of how they want to play.

That’s why Stefanski likes to throw on first down with short passes. There are more options to guard against when it is 2nd and 4, than when it is 2nd and 9.

It’s not all about the play calling and the QB, although that’s what the radio talk shows will hammer you over the head with.

We are sure the front office knows these things as well, and will work for improvement. That’s what you do every off-season.

Browns, Baker, OBJ: It Just Didn’t Fit

The knee-jerk reaction to the events that occurred this week with the Cleveland Browns is to declare the age old saying “same ol’ Browns”. That’s not entirely fair.

The old Browns, the ones led by Hue Jackson, Joe Banner, etc. seemed different. The head coach and the GM usually seemed like they were on different pages and many times one sabotaged the other.

This current group, with Paul DePodesta, GM Andrew Berry, and coach Kevin Stefanski, seem to be on the same page. They come to decisions together, they don’t seem to be running to owner Jimmy Haslam to point out a mistake made by one of the others in order to gain more power within the organization.

We don’t know what brought the situation with Odell Beckham Jr. to a head, but in our viewpoint, the front office dealt with it swiftly and decisively.

Our opinion was the video put out by Beckham’s dad, released a day before the trading deadline, was a move to force the front office to trade the wide receiver. Perhaps Beckham, if frustration, went to Stefanski and requested a quarterback change, and was told there would not be one.

But when Berry couldn’t reach a deal that made sense for the Browns, Stefanski, Berry, and DePodesta decided it was time to cut ties with the wide out. The reason Beckham was told to stay away from practice on Wednesday and Thursday was the negotiations were taking place with his agent to release him or put him on waivers.

Whatever, the situation was didn’t work out in Cleveland. First, OBJ has the reputation and carries himself like an elite pass catcher, but the fact is he hasn’t been one since 2016, when he caught 101 passes for 1367 yards with the Giants.

The following season, the injuries started, ironically in a pre-season game against the Browns, when a hit by Briean Boddy-Calhoun caused a sprained ankle. Beckham and the Giants claimed it was a dirty hit, but in our view at the time, it looked perfectly legal.

OBJ missed most of the 2017 season, playing just four games, and the following year, his numbers dropped to 77 catches for 1052 yards, and was traded to the Browns following that season.

He played through a core injury in ’19, but barely had 1000 yards receiving (1035), catching 74 passes. Last year, it was the torn ACL, and this year a shoulder injury.

There is no evidence he was a bad guy in the locker room, but did he have the same priority as the other players? As former Steelers’ coach Bill Cowher said yesterday, would OBJ rather catch eight passes in a Browns’ loss than catch one pass in a Cleveland victory?

We have been on teams with players like that, and it makes one roll their eyes.

You also have to think about the fact (and it isn’t anecdotal, the numbers are real) that Baker Mayfield has better numbers with Beckham not on the field than with him on the field. Now, we don’t have empirical evidence as to why that’s true, but if Baker has a good game today, it will be brought up again.

In football, sometimes a player isn’t a good fit in a particular offense.

History gives us a similar situation, ironically involving the same teams. After the Browns traded Paul Warfield to get Mike Phipps prior to the 1970 draft, feeling they needed to replace Warfield, Cleveland traded for Giants’ WR Homer Jones, who made two Pro Bowls, and averaged over 20 yards per catch with New York.

Jones had those gaudy numbers in part, because he found open spots while Fran Tarkenton, a scrambler, ran away from pressure. With the Browns, and a regular drop back passer in Bill Nelsen, Jones caught just 10 passes for 141 yards and a single touchdown.

He was out of the league the next season.

Sometimes, it just doesn’t fit. That seems to sum up Odell Beckham Jr.’s time with the Browns.

Tracking The Browns Rebuild

Now that the Cleveland Browns have returned to being a good football team, the discussions about who should get the credit for the success rages on for some folks.

This rebuilding process started following the 2015 season when Mike Pettine and GM Ray Farmer were let go and replaced by Sashi Brown, a lawyer who came out of nowhere to be the de facto GM of the Browns.

Brown’s plan was essentially to stop putting bandages on the roster every season and to start from scratch. He traded or released just about every veteran, and armed the organization with a bunch of draft picks.

Hue Jackson was hired as the head coach, and we would think he was informed what was about to happen to the roster.

The plan was at the time unheard of, no team had done this in the NFL, although to Sashi’s credit, it seems like subsequently, the Dolphins, Jets, and now the Jaguars are doing the same thing.

Cleveland had the second overall pick in ’16, and Brown traded that pick to Philadelphia (which became Carson Wentz) and the Browns wound up with WR Corey Coleman. The team did draft Emmanuel Ogbah, Carl Nassib, Joe Schobert, and WR Rashard Higgins, who is still contributing.

The result of the total rebuild in the first year was a 1-15 record, which netted the organization the first overall pick in 2017, and they selected Myles Garrett. Critics will point out they passed on Patrick Mahomes (10th overall) and could have selected Deshaun Watson at #12, but they traded down to get more picks.

Cleveland also got Jabrill Peppers and David Njoku in the first round and DT Larry Ogunjobi in the third round.

The rebuild got sidetracked with Jackson, unhappy with the losing, although again, we have to assume he knew the plan, complained to owner Jimmy Haslam (probably a lot). Brown was fired and replaced with “football guy” John Dorsey, formerly a GM with Kansas City.

Dorsey brought a “win now” mentality with him and after an 0-16 season, selected QB Baker Mayfield with the first overall pick in ’18, CB Denzel Ward with the 4th overall pick, and used a 2nd rounder to get Nick Chubb, three main cogs of the 2020 Browns.

Beyond that trio, the rest of the draft was a flop. No players remain on the roster. Still, the three who stayed are pretty good.

However, after a 7-8-1 season that featured wins in five of the last seven games, Dorsey got greedy (figuratively) and traded his first round pick, Peppers, and his starting right guard in Kevin Zeitler for WR Odell Beckham and DE Olivier Vernon.

However, his biggest mistake was thinking the chemistry of the offensive coordinator, who took over when Jackson and his OC, Todd Haley was fired mid-season, and Mayfield was enough to make Freddie Kitchens the head coach.

Meanwhile, chief strategy office Paul DePodesta, who came to the organization with Sashi Brown, wanted to hire Minnesota assistant Kevin Stefanski.

While bringing in Beckham, the rest of Dorsey’s draft that year hasn’t been impressive. Second rounder CB Greedy Williams, while showing promise, has been injured, and the next best player is LB Sione Takitaki, who is serviceable.

After Kitchens was given the gate following a 6-10 season, it seems like Dorsey left the organization because his voice wasn’t the most prominent during the coaching search, which wound up in the hands of Stefanski, DePodesta’s choice all along.

Andrew Berry, also part of the Sashi Brown front office was brought back, this time as GM.

His first draft appears to be a good one, with OT Jedrick Wills being a starter from day one, and several contributors with upside, notably LB Jacob Phillips, TE Harrison Bryant, and WR Donovan Peoples-Jones.

And don’t forget S Grant Delpit, who figured to start before his achilles injury in camp.

Sashi laid out the plan and he, DePodesta, and Berry started to lay it out before the ownership got impatient. Dorsey made the bad hire as head coach, but did bring in Mayfield, Ward, and Chubb, and the Browns aren’t 10-4 without them.

He didn’t fill out the roster though, but Berry came back to take care of that, adding solid free agents in T Jack Conklin and TE Austin Hooper.

The question is, could this success have arrived a year or so ago had DePodesta got his way and hired Stefanski after 2018? Thankfully, it was just a one year delay.