After the Beatles broke up in 1970, one of the first singles produced by drummer Ringo Starr was a song called “It Don’t Come Easy” (written by George Harrison, by the way). That song perfectly describes Game 4 of the AL Division Series in Chicago last night.
The Guardians staved off elimination again with a seesaw 9-5 verdict to force a fifth and deciding game in Cleveland on Saturday night.
When pitchers show fatigue, it usually affects command and perhaps that’s why starter Parker Messick walked four hitters in his 2.1 innings, and that he couldn’t get through four or five innings set in motion in essence a bullpen game, and some questionable decisions by Steven Vogt.
Trailing 2-0, the Guardians bounced back on homers by Patrick Bailey and Jose Ramirez to take a 3-2 lead. So, Vogt brought in Tanner Bibee for the first relief appearance of his career. We understand the why, the skipper wanted length, but Bibee hasn’t had a good year, and didn’t pitch well in September.
He walked two of the three hitters he faced, including the leadoff man, and Vogt had to go to Tim Herrin, who gave up a hit to load the bases, and then hit a batter and gave up a sacrifice fly, and poof, the lead had disappeared and Cleveland trailed 4-3.
Eventually, Erik Sabrowski was summoned after another base on balls and got the third out.
Then, the Cleveland bats went to work. It started with Angel Martinez, who is 0 for 15 in the series getting hit by a pitch and then stealing second. Five hits and two walks later, the Guardians put six runs on the board to take a 9-4 lead. The big blows were the game tying double by Travis Bazzana, a single by Bailey to put them ahead, and a two run single by Jo Adell.
Sabrowski and Hunter Gaddis, who has been shaky as of late, actually restored order.
We also didn’t like trying to use Cade Smith for two innings. These guys aren’t Strat-O-Matic cards, fatigue is a factor. At the time, we would have left Gaddis in to get one or two more outs. Which brings up another question.
If you don’t think Matt Festa can get three outs without giving up four runs, then why is he on the post-season roster?
The point is we would have limited Smith to one inning. And Vogt had to use Gavin Williams to close it out.
So, now it’s a winner take all game Saturday night. No doubt the Guardians will see Sean Burke, who pitched 5.1 innings of one hit ball in Game 2 and has a 2.56 ERA in his career against Cleveland with 46 Ks in 36.2 innings.
That’s a tough task.
Gavin Williams will start for the Guardians, but likely with a shorter rope since he pitched yesterday. But it would not be a surprise if everyone pitches, but that’s a deciding game for you.
After losing the first two at home, the Guardians fought back, and need to get that first win in front of the home folks.