First, let’s discuss the decision. Browns’ coach Todd Monken received many virtual pats on the back tor going for the win in Sunday’s 23-22 loss to the New Orleans Saints. We believe that’s because by and large, football people are aggressive and they like players and coaches to be aggressive. They want them to “go for it!”
And frankly, if the Browns came into the contest 2-6 or 3-5 instead of 5-3, going for the win would have been the correct call. But the reality is they did have a winning record for the season. Look, a tie is better than a loss in a playoff race.
As of this moment, the Browns are tied with New England for the seventh and final spot in the AFC playoffs. It’s unexpected for sure. But, if they’d have tied on Sunday, guess what? They’d be in the 7th spot all by themselves. There’s a time and place to push the envelope and with a minute to go in overtime with the Saints having no timeouts, that wasn’t it.
Remember, the Browns were also stopped inside the five earlier in the game so we had no confidence they could get two yards when needed.
And yes, we said that live. This is not a second guess.
Now, as for the actual action, the old problem plagued the Browns again, that is, they can’t run the ball and they can’t stop the run. Mike Rutenberg’s unit allowed 160 yards rushing, the third straight week over 140 yards and over the last five contests, the Cleveland defense has allowed an average of 144.4 yards on the ground.
They are 6th worst in the league against the run, ahead of only the Raiders, Cowboys, Colts, Saints and Panthers. And none of those teams have winning records. As good as the Browns’ secondary is, they are rendered useless if the other team doesn’t have to throw the ball to succeed.
And for the people saying Saints’ QB Tyler Shough had 51 of those yards, yes, that is a product of playing man-to-man defense, but since they play that way (a better way to play, by the way) the pass rushers have to contain him in the pocket.
Conversely, Cleveland’s rushing attack continues to be uninspiring. The Browns have rushed for over 100 yards just three times (all wins) and is in the bottom 10 in the NFL in that category.
The Browns have offensive line issues, but we felt before the season that maybe the team needs to do better than Quinshon Judkins, who is averaging just 3.3 yards per carry and doesn’t seem to have good vision in finding lanes to run.
The lack of the running game keeps putting the quarterback, either Deshaun Watson or Shedeur Sanders in bad situations and with a shaky line, that means the defensive line can pin their ears back and go after the passer.
The Browns next four games are at home starting Sunday against Houston (their GM is former University School and John Carroll grad Nick Caserio). The Texans are 3-5, but were a playoff team a year ago. Do we have confidence in this team? Not really.
Monken’s team hasn’t been great, but they are in the hunt at 5-4. If there is a decent blocking tight end out there, the Browns should be trying to get him, because they need Harold Fannin, who is averaging 12.2 yards per reception with a team high four TDs to be a receiver, not a blocker.
And on that note, please get the ball to Denzel Boston more.