It seems since after the Browns win over Houston last weekend, the Browns and Browns’ adjacent folks are talking about a contract extension for QB Deshaun Watson. The adjacent part would be those on the payroll of outlets who depend on the franchise for content, meaning the two sports talk radio stations in town (both broadcast their games) and many of the newspaper people who cover the team.
Coincidence? We allow you to make your own conclusion.
Look, Watson has played better than anyone could’ve imagined at the beginning of the season. And he has led Todd Monken’s squad to six come from behind victories in the fourth quarter. No one can take that away from him.
But let’s not mistake this for understanding the Browns still aren’t getting above average play from the position. They are in the fourth quarter for sure, but would some of those comebacks in the final quarter not have been necessary had Watson played better early in games?
We all know the answer to that.
We say this all the time, but passer rating is not the true measure of great quarterback play, but that said, Watson ranks 18th in league in this category right in between Bryce Young and Kyler Murray, who has been benched in Minnesota.
And we could go a step further to see where he would rank without the sterling play in the fourth quarter. We can imagine he would be near the bottom of the league.
If you look at QBR, ESPN’s system of rating the position, Watson is 26th, between Jameis Winston and Justin Herbert. Should the Browns’ front office be thinking they could get better play in 2027 and beyond? Absolutely.
What we would be thinking is simply this: Watson has been here since 2022 and largely has not played well. Is that due to the scheme he played in previously? Perhaps. However, we will use a baseball analogy here, after several mediocre seasons, a player has a career season. Do you really think that’s the player he is now, or will he regress to the mean.
We’d bet on the latter.
Let’s look at the last QB in a Cleveland uniform to lead a lot of comeback victories, Brian Sipe, who is beloved in town. Sipe was a good passer, throwing for 2900 yards in 1978, and leading the league in TDs in ’79 with 28 (with 26 picks!) and throwing for almost 3800 yards, at a time when the NFL record was just over 4000 (Joe Namath).
In 1980, Sipe put it all together, winning league MVP with 4132 yards (second to Dan Fouts) and 30 touchdowns with just 14 interceptions. And the Browns won the division.
What happened the following year? The yardage dropped to 3876, the scoring throws dropped to 17, and the picks went back up to 25. And the Browns went from 11-5 to 5-11. He remained the starter until 1983, when he left to join the USFL.
Our point? Don’t be fooled by what looks to be a “magical” year.
We look at it like we look at analytics which showed the Cavs’ best lineup contained Dean Wade. Wade wasn’t the reason; he just happened to be out there with four other real good players.
We don’t know who will be available, but if Andrew Berry can find someone who can play QB at a higher-level next year, the Browns will be better off and might be able to have back-to-back successful seasons.
Are we ruling Watson out? No, but there is no reason to talk about it now. Let’s see how the rest of the season plays out.