This Year, Spring Training Doesn’t Hold The Same Excitement

We have made no bones about the fact that baseball is our favorite sport. And usually, this time of year has us excited. Spring training is about to begin, and like many fans, we put together potential lineups in our head and think about what young prospects could make a difference for the Guardians.

We don’t have that same feeling this winter.

Part of it is the sports itself and how it is covered. When MLB Network first came out, we loved it. A station that talked nothing about what used to be the “national pastime.”

Much of the winter was spent showing old games, where we could show our children players like Sandy Koufax, Pete Rose, Joe Morgan, Roberto Clemente, and even Mark “The Bird” Fidrych.

Now, the network has turned into group think, where no one has diverse opinions and much of the talk is solely about sabremetric statistics, which we do pay attention to, but we are starting to see “analytics” as a justification to make a decision.

For example, the Guardians played Gabriel Arias at shortstop most of the last two months because he has an outstanding exit velocity, meaning he hits the ball hard. The problem for Arias though, is he rarely hits it.

None of the guys we grew up playing baseball with think Arias is a good player. None.

There is a place in the sport for these numbers, but it would be okay if someone talked about runs scored, RBI, and disagreed that a good player should make the Hall of Fame.

Besides, how many times can you watch Little Big League?

But it is the local situation that really has us not looking forward to the season with the same zeal.

The Cleveland Guardians won the AL Central Division in 2022, and at the all-star break last season, were still in the race. Then, at the trading deadline, they moved one of their starting pitchers, even though they had two starters injured, and moved one of their middle of the order bats.

When the division leading Twins failed to pull away in August, and Terry Francona announced he was going to retire at the end of the season, they did claim three pitchers to bolster the staff to make a belated run.

It failed.

The Guardians’ offense is the chief problem, ranking 12th in the American League in runs scored. It would seem to be the area where the club could improve and vault into the post-season in 2024. However, the organization did nothing.

Yes, we know, in fact, we all know about the broadcast deal with Bally Sports. We all know because the ownership through the media tells fans about it all the time. We have said this often, if the people who pay the bills put as much energy in trying to make the team better and/or get more fans to the park as they do making excuses why they can’t spend money, the Guardians would be better off.

The team couldn’t even make a big announcement that the equipment truck was leaving for Arizona yesterday, a glimmer of spring hope in northeast Ohio, until several media outlets reported it was happening.

We lived through the Vernon Stouffer years, the Nick Mileti years, the Gabe Paul years, etc., and through the naivety of youth, still believed the Indians could contend. Fifty years later, and nothing has changed.

It used to be because the old decrepit base park that the team couldn’t compete. Now we have Progressive Field, and outside of the first ten years it was built, the excuse is the same.

We understand the finances of the game is a problem, and smaller markets are at a disadvantage, but we are certain the family who owns the Guardians is doing quite well. A good businessman finds another way.

We still love baseball, but we feel let down by it. We are sure someone will read this and say “go root for another team!”, but we grew up with the Cleveland Indians, and we are born and bred here.

The owners are the stewards of the franchise. Yet they continue to let us down. Fifty years from now, will there be fans like the guys we grew up with?

Looking At The Way Sports Are Covered Today

You hear this on sports talk shows and on social media after games. Fans wondering why reporters, both print and broadcast media, don’t ask the manager or coach tough questions about the contest. The answer is quite simple. Covering sports in today’s age has changed greatly.

First, the man in charge generally isn’t going to call out a player in the media, so asking about a player making a key mistake or not putting out the best effort is fruitless. The question will be asked, so the reporter doesn’t lose his credibility, but he knows the inquiry will not be answered. The only time the manager or coach will do it is if the player is on his way out of town.

And we have seen cantankerous relationships between teams and reporters who persist in asking questions the organizations do not want to address. Quite frankly, those reporters are trying to do their job, but on the other hand, they can’t without the cooperation of the team they cover.

It’s a chicken or the egg problem.

From a national standpoint, each of the major professional sports leagues have their own network, so listen closely to hear anything negative about any team or any sport.

NBA TV is mostly a pure lovefest. They focus on the individual great plays and not really on teams until the playoffs. We feel this is a reaction to the younger fans of basketball, who are fans of individual players more than teams.

The MLB Network has followed this formula as well. They will show a player belting a 450-foot home run, ignoring that his team lost, and he struck out in his other three at bats.

Both networks cater to the bigger markets. We tuned in to NBA TV after the Cavaliers knocked off Boston on the road, only to listen to the panel discuss the winless Lakers for 15 minutes. As for baseball, their network barely mentioned the Guardians all year until they made the post-season.

Locally, both the Guardians and Cavaliers have their own broadcasts of most games, and the announcers and pregame hosts are partners with the teams. This isn’t necessarily totally a bad thing, because you do get a lot of insight fans would not have received in the old days.

Both Andre Knott for the Guardians and Serena Winters for the Cavs seem to have developed great relationships with the players and therefore, viewers have seen the personality of the players, which helps fans of the team relate.

Just don’t expect them to ask “hard hitting” questions. That’s not their jobs.

There are also “influencers” on social media to talk up the teams and present favorable points of view on both the players and entire organization. Just another way for them to get their message out there. For example, we saw a number of comments from the Cavs’ group during training camp talking about how good Isaac Okoro is, and getting excited about Mamadi Diakite.

There is nothing wrong with this, however, folks listening, or reading should be aware of where the content is coming from.

It’s really nothing new. In the old days when newspapers were in their heyday, it has been said several star players had reporters as “mouthpieces”. Ford Frick, who eventually became the Commissioner of Baseball, was said to have served that function for Babe Ruth in the 1920’s.

Of course, Frick was the man who put the asterisk on Roger Maris’ 61 homers in 1961 because the season had expanded to 162 games. But we are sure there wasn’t a conflict of interest there.

It’s just a different day and age these days. Each sport and each team try to control the message. That’s nothing new. However, credibility should be questioned by the person consuming the message.

That’s a whole different problem in society. Thinking for yourself.

Baseball Needs Leadership, Manfred Ain’t The Guy

Baseball is out of the public eye these days because of the lockout enforced by the owners, and their seemingly unwillingness to sit down at the negotiating table to hammer out a new Collective Bargaining Agreement.

We have read reports the two sides will return to the bargaining table soon, but hey, it’s no rush guys, spring training doesn’t start until the middle of next month.

When they are in the news now, you can predict it is usually for the wrong reasons, such as when it was announced one of the best baseball writers in the business, Ken Rosenthal, was no longer going to be affiliated with MLB Network.

Apparently, Rosenthal was critical of commissioner Rob Manfred for how he handled the sport during the shortened pandemic season of 2020, and the czar holds a grudge.

Talk about pettiness. Can’t we all agree the commissioner of a major sport should be above something like that?

Rosenthal will be just fine. First, he loves the sports and is a great writer, and he still writes for The Athletic, and he is part of Fox Network’s baseball coverage.

To us, it just is another example of the poor leadership exemplified by Manfred, who we wonder if he even likes the sport.

The problem is the commissioner is hired by the owners, and they look at the sport as a way to fill their pockets with massive amounts of cash, without regard to the future of the grand ol’ game.

All pretenses that the commissioner is the puppet of ownership was put to rest when Bud Selig, the then owner of the Milwaukee Brewers, replaced Fay Vincent in the position, because the owners felt Vincent intervened during the 1990 lockout of the players.

The big question to us is why should the selection of the commissioner fall solely on the owners? This automatically means the leadership of the sport favors one side in any dispute, and that’s the side he works for.

How convenient, right?

We know it will never happen, but it would be nice if the commissioner of the sport held the well being of both parties in making decisions. Especially because the players are the game. Ballparks all over the country are not being filled to watch the owners count their money.

The sport needs a strong leader now more than ever, and we have serious questions whether Manfred even likes the sport he is in charge of.

What the game has going for it more than anything else is tradition. Essentially, the game being played today is the same sport that Babe Ruth played, that Jackie Robinson played. You can’t say that about football or basketball.

Baseball needs to change, and the problem is not the way Manfred and the owners want. Right now, we believe the players have more of the sports’ best interests at heart than the people running it.

That’s scary.

Has Manfred made any decisions since he took office that didn’t make you shake your head? And if the owners are putting him up to this, what does that say about them?

Heck, we have severe problems with the owners of our team.

This new CBA would be a good starting point in giving the players some say in picking the commissioner. Or perhaps having the owners keep that power but pick a former player for the job.

Something has to change for the good and for the future of the sport. And we hope the commissioner doesn’t ban us from buying tickets because we criticized him.

Manfred Rights A Wrong?

MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred finally said something that will make true baseball fans happy on Tuesday when he announced the seven inning doubleheaders and the addition of a runner on second base in extra innings may not be part of the sport come 2022.

Whether or not he means it or it is simply a negotiating issue for when the CBA ends after this season is up for debate, because the commissioner hasn’t seemed like a guy working for the purists of the sport up to now.

As evidence, we present you the All Star Game uniforms worn during the Midsummer Classic.

The shortened games were loved by those who want to change the grand ‘ol game because it doesn’t hold their interest. Can you imagine the uproar in the NFL announced their Thursday night game would only be three quarters because of the short time in between games?

Or the NBA announced when both team were playing the second game of a back-to-back set, the second game would only be 40 minutes?

We don’t hear many true fans of baseball who think these changes were good for the sport.

Besides, have you ever been to an NFL game live? There’s a lot of downtime in football too. Think about after a touchdown, there’s a commercial, the kickoff, and likely another commercial. If you are at the game, that’s a lot of time where nothing is happening on the field.

We have said it before, if baseball wants to address the pace of play, it’s a rather simple fix. Stop allowing hitters to get out of the batter’s box after every pitch, particularly if they take the pitch. There shouldn’t be anything to adjust if you are just standing there.

Another target to “fix” the game is eliminating shifts. Why should you limit the way another team defends a batter? It’s one thing if a pitch is inside for the batter to try and pull, but how many times do you see a hitter try to pull an outside pitch when the opposite field (at least on the infield) is pulled over to the point the third baseman is playing shortstop?

Besides, it’s not like no one can hit the ball where defenders are not. Players like Michael Brantley, Xander Bogaerts, Trey Turner, and Cedric Mullins are all hitting over .310. It can be done.

While the commish is making changes (or correcting bad decisions) for 2022, let’s request the end of pitchers hitting in the National League. A universal DH for all of organized baseball!

If baseball wants to help its image, perhaps they should stop talking about all of the problems in the sport. You don’t hear Roger Goodell talking about the horrible officiating in the sport, right? Or Adam Silver talking about how 75% of his franchises are largely irrelevant.

Having the game evolve into a glorified home run derby isn’t good for the game, but when MLB Network shows highlight after highlight of homers, what do young people think?

It’s the same as the NBA when the four letter network started showing just dunks and three pointers as part of their package. Guess what kids start working on at the playground?

The game and the network seems to be fixated on Shohei Ohtani and Fernando Tatis Jr. in promoting the game’s young talent. We would broaden that to even more of the great young players in the sport, like Vlade Guerrero Jr., Rafael Devers, Ronald Acuna Jr., etc.

As for the swinging for the fences (and missing), sports are filled with copycats. Currently, the Astros lead everyone is runs scored, and they are doing it by striking out the least times of any team.

Other teams will look at that and think…maybe we can do that.

The best thing Manfred and his office can do this winter? Avoid a labor stoppage with the players. Not having baseball in the spring will drive the casual fans away.

That’s the worst kind of public relations.