Seeing Good Things In A Browns Victory

Last week, we said this would be a big week for Browns’ defensive coordinator Mike Rutenberg because of the way his unit was gashed in the opening week loss to Jacksonville. We thought it was a test of a coaches’ ego, he wanted to play a certain way and would he adapt after the poor performance.

Good for the coach and head coach Todd Monken that they made adjustments, and the result was a 23-19 victory over Tampa Bay and raised their record to 1-1 on the young season. The Browns’ defense was better, causing the game’s only turnover, an interception by Myles Harden, and allowed the Buccaneers to cross the goal line just once.

As for the offense, Monken said he simplified things on that side of the ball, which is great coaching. After getting blown out in game one, there was a lot of improvement and that’s a good thing to see if you are a fan.

For all of the quarterback talk during the week and even prior to kickoff, Deshaun Watson played well, not tremendously, but well, and that’s not a criticism. He didn’t turn the ball over, was sacked just twice, keeping the negative plays to a minimum.

He mostly dinked and dunked, which isn’t necessarily a bad thing, completing 24 of 30 throws for 238 yards, and two TDs. He completed only three passes for over 15 yards, and two of them were the scoring throws. He also led the team in rushing for the second straight week, which is not a good thing, but more on that later.

The running game was nonexistent, getting just 44 yards on 23 rushing attempts with Quinshon Judkins getting only 21 yards on 12 carries, with an early carry being his longest, that of nine yards.

We have our doubts on how long the offense can be effective with no running game to speak of and a QB who doesn’t seem to want to push the ball down the field. But it worked against Tampa and a win is most definitely a win.

One player who has caught our eye on offense is rookie WR Denzel Boston. We were disappointed when the Browns chose KC Concepcion in the first round because we thought the team needed a big wideout but were thrilled getting him in the second round. He’s caught 7 passes in the first two games for 154 yards and two touchdowns.

In the second half, Cleveland was faced with a third and seven (or so) situation and our thought was find Boston. Watson did for a key first down. Monken and offensive coordinator Travis Switzer should be trying to get the ball in his hands more often.

On the defensive side, last year’s first round pick, Mason Graham looks like a standout. He had a sack for the second week in a row, and the reigning defensive rookie of the year, Carson Schwesinger, had ten tackles and a big play on the final drive when he corralled Baker Mayfield on a key third down.

The best thing about the win is a week off from talking about tanking and replacing the QB. Watson needs to continue to play well, avoiding turnovers and not sacking himself. Can he do that? We will see.

Besides, tanking is stupid and doesn’t work.

Monken’s crew finally comes home to take on Carolina next Sunday. Hopefully, this game is something to build on.

Pressure On Rutenberg And The Defense Too.

As we wrote a couple of weeks ago, coaches have egos. They like to put their stamp on things, to show they made a difference. We are sure that Browns’ defensive coordinator, Mike Rutenberg, is no different.

Rutenberg will be 45 next month and this is his first gig as a defensive coordinator. He started as an intern with Washington at age 22, went to the college ranks, and has been in the NFL since 2013 where he was an assistant defensive backs coach with the Jaguars. So, he’s a guy who has worked his way up the coaching ranks and getting his first opportunity to run a professional defense.

On the other hand, he took over a Cleveland defense that just a year ago, Steelers’ coach Mike Tomlin said was the best unit in the AFC North. ranking in the top five defenses in the league three times in the last five years under Jim Schwartz.

In the words of Charles Barkley, “if it ain’t broke, don’t break it”.

To be fair, Rutenberg was put a little behind the eight ball when the Browns traded the two-time Defensive Player of the Year in Myles Garrett. But they did replace Garrett with a Pro Bowl player in Jared Verse. Still, that’s a drop off.

But the nature of coach’s egos is making something better. And we raised an eyebrow during training camp when Rutenberg said he wanted to play more zone defense, even though his starting cornerbacks, All Pro Denzel Ward and Tyson Campbell, both excel in playing man-to-man.

We believe that in both football and basketball, man-to-man is the preferred style of defense. Zone defense is used because you can’t play man-to-man. And we understand in football, you can’t play man on every down.

In the season opener, the Browns’ defense, previously the strength of the team, was shredded by Jacksonville, giving up 360 yards, including 126 on the ground. And that was with the Jaguars taking their foot off the gas in the fourth quarter.

Watching the Jaguars’ completions down field, many of them were against a zone defense, which will happen if you can’t put pressure on the QB, and Cleveland had only one sack. Any decent passer, given time, will find the holes in a zone.

We bring all of this up because this week we will see what kind of defensive coordinator Mike Rutenberg will be. Will he be so sure of his convictions that the Browns will use the same schemes this week against Tampa Bay? Or will he listen to his players, some of whom seemed puzzled by all of the zone looks.

A lot of the focus will be on the quarterback, and has there been improvement at that position from week one, but the game against the Jaguars was a blowout because the defense was terrible, allowing 24 points in the first half.

If that unit isn’t better, it will really be a long season because most experts figured the defense could keep the Browns in games.

No pressure on the new coach though.

Didn’t Have High Expectations, But Browns Looked Worse

We weren’t very optimistic about the Cleveland Browns’ chance last Sunday against the Jacksonville Jaguars, but quite frankly the game was worse than we thought.

This one was over at halftime with the Jaguars holding a 24-0 advantage in route to cruising to a 34-10 beatdown in Todd Monken’s head coaching debut. It was everything the biggest Browns’ pessimist could have feared.

The second half was a bunch of garbage time so the end of game stats don’t look as bad as it was. Deshaun Watson wound up completing 16 of 22 throws for 205 yards and a 46 yard touchdown pass to rookie Denzel Boston, who wasn’t a factor in the first half for some unknown reason.

The game started okay with a good kickoff return by Dylan Sampson and Watson clicking on some short throws and moving the Browns for a couple of first downs. Then came the big mistake, an interception by Foyesade Oluokun on a pass over the middle where it seemed like Watson never saw him. There have been reports of similar plays throughout training camp by the folks who cover the team on a daily basis.

We were concerned about the defense with the loss of veteran coordinator Jim Schwartz and the best defensive player in the league (and franchise history) Myles Garrett, and those fears were warranted. The new guy in charge, Mike Rutenberg, said he was going to play more zone, and Jags’ QB Trevor Lawrence chewed up that coverage, targeting the weaker links in the secondary, outside of one play where Tyson Campbell had good coverage.

It will be interesting to see what Rutenberg learns from the defeat and goes back to more man coverage. Because it seems the personnel is more suited to that style. By the way, the Browns had only one sack, by Mason Graham and didn’t put much pressure on Lawrence, so maybe Garrett was missed even though he didn’t show leadership.

Offensively, beside Watson’s issues, we believe Monken wants to run the ball, but when you fall behind by 17 points midway through the second quarter, that plan goes out the window. Quinshon Judkins had just 33 yards on 12 carries, as Watson led Cleveland in rushing with 38 yards.

It does seem crazy to have a QB who had three serious injuries over the past four years running read option plays, but that’s a question for the coaching staff.

Watson was sacked five times, but we didn’t think the rebuilt offensive line was visibly bad. As usual, the QB sacked himself a few times, and former NFL offensive lineman LeCharles Bentley (Iggy grad) pointed out he retreated after taking the snap in the shotgun. That doesn’t help the linemen.

As we said before, Boston seemed an afterthought in the first half, perhaps because the quarterback can’t make the sideline throw from the pocket and he was lined up outside. The other rookie receiver, KC Concepcion caught four passes for 43 yards and ran three times for 15 more.

Last year’s leading receiver, Harold Fannin, also was missing in the first half, and caught two balls after halftime when again the Jaguars’ defense was playing very loose.

It couldn’t have gone worse for the new coaching staff in their debut, and the first test comes next week against Tampa Bay with an angry QB in Baker Mayfield and coming off a loss in their opener. Will Monken and Rutenberg stubbornly stay with what didn’t work or will they start taking advantage of what talent they have?