You wouldn’t think there would much debate about the merits of an NBA team that has won 60 games total over the past three seasons. The normal school of thought would be the team isn’t very good, right?
Welcome to Cleveland, Ohio where there is a lot of discussion about the rebuilding process involving the Cavaliers. There are plenty of people who will tell you the franchise is making progress toward a return to the playoffs, and an equal number who contend the team is stuck in the mud.
We fall in the latter category, mostly because we take a traditional view in terms of how successful teams are built in any sport. Yes, someone may come up with different approach that gets some success in the short term, but usually what happens is the smart people within the sport figure out how to combat the new view and render it meaningless.
Examples in other sports are the “wildcat” formation in the NFL and launch angle in baseball. In the latter example, teams started teaching pitchers to throw higher in the strike zone.
The supporters of the direction of the wine and gold talk about the “exciting, young core” of talent GM Koby Altman has accumulated since LeBron James departed via free agency three years ago, but you would be hard pressed to find anyone outside of Cleveland who shares this viewpoint of Collin Sexton, Darius Garland, Isaac Okoro, and Jarrett Allen.
And we have said this before in this space, but don’t talk to us about statistics when trying to evaluate players. To us, the last thing we use to figure out who played well in any basketball game is the stat sheet. The old saying of a player does things that don’t show in the box score is very true in hoops.
Players have to fit together, play off each other, and do things to make their teammates better. If they do that, the team is better and the ultimate statistic to determine that is in the wins and losses columns. Right now, those columns show the rebuilding effort is not working.
The 2020-21 Cavs weren’t a team that played tough most nights and just came up short either. This is a team that lost 17 games (by our count) by 20 points or more. They ranked 28th of 30 teams in offensive rating and 25th in defensive rating, meaning they weren’t any good on either side of the floor.
This isn’t an indictment on the players, and certainly not a criticism of their work ethic either. We have given credit to Altman in the past for not have any “knuckleheads” on the team, guys who get in trouble off the court. Kevin Porter Jr. had some issues and the team moved on from him quickly, perhaps too quickly.
We also aren’t picking on players who just came into the league either. We love watching Luka Doncic and Ja Morant play. We have had an issue in the past with Trae Young, but it appears Nate McMillan spoke to him about being more like an NBA point guard, and less trying to be the next Stephen Curry. Doing that helped transform the Atlanta Hawks.
This is a big summer for the Cavs’ organization. Next season will determine whether or not they can be like Atlanta and be a playoff presence or Sacramento or Minnesota, franchises continually floundering.
However, they need to stop presenting all kinds of reasons why they are going in the right direction. It’s a bit like peeing in the wind and telling the fans it’s raining.