Browns Need A Lot Of Help In Draft. Do They Have The Right Formula For Picking?

The NFL Draft is now less than three weeks away and as we do in northeast Ohio, there is obsession about who the Cleveland Browns will take in the selection process, but particularly what they will do with their two picks in the first round.

The draft obsessed fans and media alike would surely love a trade down because more picks!!! And to be fair, it would make sense if the organization really liked someone and were sure said player would be available say four or five picks later.

But, you can’t mess that up.

As stated before, we have no confidence in anything that happens in Berea, so until proven otherwise, we will assume whatever they do probably won’t work or will be done with the idea of winning three years from now.

Yes, we know last year’s draft looks to be very good, but time will tell, and if a baseball player hit .220 four years in a row, then hit .300 in a season, what would you predict he will hit next season?

The logical needs for the Browns would seem to be wide receiver and offensive line, but the Cleveland Browns are also a bad football team. They’ve won eight games over the last two seasons. To say if they only had a couple of good pass catchers and two solid offensive linemen, they would be Super Bowl contenders would seem insane.

What we are trying to say here is the Browns need talent, another draft like last year, where they bring in say, four quality starters (Mason Graham, Carson Schwesinger, Quinshon Judkins, and Harold Fannin Jr.) would be a good start to getting better.

We know the Browns have the best defensive player in the NFL in Myles Garrett (no, we don’t care if he skips OTAs), but if you can get a player like David Bailey, DE from Texas Tech, to pair with Garrett, it is something to think about.

Remember what former Browns (when they were good) executive Ernie Accorsi said. The two most important players on the field are quarterback and the guy who can get to the quarterback. Having a pair of edge rushers to terrorize opposing passers wouldn’t be the worst thing.

We also know the analytics people say not to draft a running back high, but let’s say you added Jim Brown to the Browns, you don’t think he would make a huge impact?

We aren’t saying Jeremiyah Love from Notre Dame is the next Jim Brown, the greatest of them all, but let’s face it, the Cleveland offense struggles to score 17 points, so adding someone who will touch the ball 15-20 times per game is a bad thing?

A tandem of Love and Judkins would seem to work, no?

Getting a franchise left tackle would be a great get and so would a reliable wide receiver to help out Shedeur Sanders. Unfortunately, the problem is the people in charge who make the picks. Maybe GM Andrew Berry has another good draft and sets the foundation for future success.

Or maybe they dump half of this year’s picks in trade for picks in 2027 under the guise of getting their “franchise QB”. You never know with the Cleveland Browns.

Browns’ Draft Thoughts

In two months, the endless draft talk regarding what the Cleveland Browns should do after a pair of horrific seasons which netted one win in 32 games.

Looking at the draft, we agree with the notion that former Browns GM Ernie Accorsi has said, the two most important positions in pro football are quarterback and a guy who can get to the quarterback.

Certainly, the brown and orange need a passer. They haven’t had one since Bernie Kosar was unceremoniously released in 1993.

They got a guy who can get to the QB last season in Myles Garrett, but like pitching in baseball, you can never have too many pass rushers.

We think Emmanuel Ogbah can develop into a great bookend with Garrett, but we think GM John Dorsey will look for another player who can get to the opposing team’s passer.

Still, we feel the offensive and defensive lines are the team’s strengths, although the Browns have to be on the lookout for Joe Thomas’ replacement whether or not he retires prior to next season or not.

Besides quarterback, in our opinion, the biggest needs for the organization are the secondary, including linebacker, and running back.

We would also say that anyone who feels the Browns can pass on a passer with the first overall pick are crazy. Again, it’s been 25 years since Cleveland has had a top 10 quarterback in the NFL.

Which one of the college QBs would we take? The guy who has the highest floor, the one who has the lowest bust factor. We think that is Josh Rosen.

Rosen was the premier prep quarterback coming into college as a freshman, meaning he was at the top of the class then, and he has maintained that position.

That said, we like Baker Mayfield a lot too. And if Dorsey and his cadre of talent evaluators think he is the answer, then we would have no problem with the Browns selecting him.

After all, if they are right, then the Browns are a step closer to competing for a Super Bowl.

There are a lot of draft “experts” who rate Penn State running back Saquon Barkley as the best player in this year’s draft.

While we certainly have seen running backs help teams transform into winners the past two seasons with Zeke Elliott in Dallas and Leonard Fournette in Jacksonville, we don’t put Barkley in the same category.

Barkley is a home run hitter, but we have questions as to whether he can take the pounding of getting 20-25 carries every week in the NFL.

Besides, this year is purported to be a deep running back draft, so you can get a solid back with one of your second round selections.

We would be more intrigued with CB/S Minkah Fitzpatrick from Alabama, DE Bradley Chubb from NC State, or CB Josh Jackson from Iowa, all of whom would fill a big need for the Browns.

We would probably look for Thomas’ replacement with one of the four selections the Browns have from pick #33 through #65, as well as one of the spots they didn’t fill with the fourth overall choice.

Trading down? We would stay away from that, in fact, we would probably look to trade back up for another first rounder.

If they would consider moving down, it should only be to drop two or three slots, so you can still get the guy you like.

There will be plenty of speculation between now and April 26th, particularly this week with NFL Draft Combine going on. Although, none of the candidates have played a game since January.

There. We got that out of our system. No more draft talk until at least April.

Is Dorsey Really A GM If He Can’t Hire The Coach?

It occurred to us today that although John Dorsey’s title is General Manager of the Cleveland Browns, he really isn’t a GM at all.

The title infers the Dorsey is managing the football operations, but as it stands right now, he is in charge of procuring players either via the waiver wire or the draft. That would make him a personnel director, not a GM.

This is because of the crazy management set up by ownership, where the Dorsey and coach Hue Jackson both report to Jimmy Haslam.

This organizational chart just invites a power struggle. And Haslam should be very familiar with this because it literally just happened.

When Sashi Brown was put in charge of the 53 man roster and Jackson was brought in as coach shortly thereafter, they claimed to be on the same page, apparently Jackson was okay with stripping down the roster and going with a total rebuild.

As the losses extended into year two of the regime, Jackson bailed on the plan, and started throwing Brown under the bus. He complained about the players, saying he didn’t have enough talent to win games.

Obviously, when we had Haslam’s ear, he kept telling the boss Brown’s plan wasn’t working and the Browns needed to bring a “football guy” in here to speed up the process.

We have no way of knowing if Sashi Brown bad mouthed the head coach in his meetings with the owner.

The disturbing thing is why would Haslam think the very same thing won’t occur again with the Dorsey/Jackson coupling?

The national media have a high opinion of Jackson, assigning him no blame to him for the horrible 1-29 record for the franchise over the last two seasons.

Locally, more and more people are realizing that Jackson is not taking the necessary steps to win football games. Better use of the running game, which would take pressure off a rookie quarterback, would be a good start.

The Browns throw more passes of 20 yards or more than any other team in the NFL, certainly not taking the pressure off DeShone Kizer.

If Dorsey is truly running the football operations, he must be free to hire his own coach. That would ensure there would be no backstabbing, and that the coach and Dorsey would be on the same page. They would have a shared vision.

Another benefit of the harmony could also be no more leaking stories of unhappiness and discord within the organization to the national media. We think we know the source of that information.

It’s a perfect time to make the move too. The Browns will likely be picking a quarterback with the first overall pick in the 2018 NFL Draft this spring. You could have your new GM, new coach, and franchise QB all coming aboard together.

This seems to be a constant issue for this franchise. Remember in the 80’s when Art Modell picked Marty Schottenheimer over the guy, Ernie Accorsi, who accumulated the talent for the teams that made three AFC title games in four years.

After a few years, Schottenheimer fell out of favor and was replaced by Bud Carson. In a matter of four years, both Accorsi and Schottenheimer were gone.

If you are going to bring in a “football guy”, then give him control of the whole shooting match. That’s the best chance to get this organization out of the malaise it has been in for over 20 years.