With Pick #2, Gotta Go QB

The Cleveland Browns will have the second overall pick in this spring’s NFL Draft. No doubt the area’s sports talk show will devote hundreds upon hundreds of hours discussing who the team should take with that selection.

The Browns need to draft a quarterback. They have to find the right person after all these years and properly get him ready to be the starter for many years to come.

We aren’t going to pretend we are football scouts and tell everyone who should be the choice. And if the Browns would have stayed around the fifth overall pick, we would have advised trading down because the team needs to get younger and faster.

Currently, the organization has 23 players 29 or older on the team. True, two of them, Dustin Hopkins and Charley Hughlett are specialists, and another, Rodney McLeod, is retiring, but there are many key players in that group.

Among them are Joel Bitonio, who may retire, Jack Conklin, Wyatt Teller, Ethan Pocic, Juan Thornhill, and Nick Chubb. And of course, the best player on the roster and the best defensive player in the league, Myles Garrett.

Another one is Deshaun Watson, but he likely will never play another down in the brown and orange, so there’s that.

When you finish 3-14 you have holes in your roster, but in listing those players, you can see more holes are about to pop up in the not-too-distant future.

But since they moved up to second, you have to identify and draft a quarterback and then be patient enough to probably not use him for the 2025 campaign.

We are aware two rookie QBs have guided their squads to the post-season in Jayden Daniels with Washington and Bo Nix in Denver. And yes, C.J. Stroud has guided the Texans to the playoffs in each of his first two seasons.

Still, more often than not, rookies struggle at the most important position in sports, so getting an opportunity to sit and watch and be mentored should be the plan.

Everyone talks about two passers in particular, Colorado’s Shadeur Sanders and Miami’s Cam Ward.

Sanders played two years at Jackson State and then two years at Colorado, while Ward started two seasons Washington State, before transferring to the Hurricanes this season.

Both have played a lot of college football, much like Daniels and Nix.

There are others who could and probably will put their names in the conversation.

We aren’t sure who will be deemed worthy of the selection by the Browns, but we do know we will hear ad nauseum about their personal workout days when they throw passes without a defense present, and media folks and fans will ooh and aah about guys completing 63 of 65 passes.

We could do the same in our backyard.

A former college quarterback once told me the most important thing a QB needs to do if read defenses. It doesn’t matter if you have a big arm or not, or how mobile you are if you know what the defense is going to do and can counter it.

As for the Browns, they can’t keep trying to patch a flat tire at that position. Many people thought they solved the problem when they drafted Baker Mayfield, but for whatever reason, the organization soured on him.

It says volumes that the last “franchise” player at the spot was Bernie Kosar, and he was drafted in 1985.

It’s time to identify and pick a player who can handle the spot for the next ten years. It just has to be done.

Unsportsmanlike Conduct After A Fair Catch. That Sums It Up

Well, you have to hand it to the Cleveland Browns. You never know what you are going to see when you watch them and Sunday’s 27-14 loss to the Steelers in Pittsburgh reminded everyone of that.

Punt returner Kadarius Toney was flagged for unsportsmanlike conduct after making a fair catch. That’s right, it wasn’t after a long return or after he made a great move to make a would-be tackler miss, he merely caught a punt and for whatever reason, decided to jaw at an opposing player.

Why he had the opportunity to muff a punt later in the 4th quarter is simply beyond us, not more on that later.

Add in two more missed field goals by Dustin Hopkins, the second occurring with a 13-7 Pittsburgh lead (meaning the game would be tied if both were made), and it will lead to more questions for the organization today.

He has now missed five of his last eight field goal attempts. In the NFL, that’s unacceptable.

During Sunday’s loss and the Monday night loss to Denver, the announcers spoke about how hard the Browns played, despite their poor record, a tribute perhaps to Kevin Stefanski.

However, is the front office failing this team right now? There hasn’t been a lot of accountability for players who are not performing from the front office.

There has been no report of kicker tryouts during the week despite Hopkins’ terrible season in which he has missed a career high nine field goals, five of those inside the 50-yard-line.

As for Toney, he should be released immediately.

But Cleveland being Cleveland, most of the conversation revolves around the quarterback.

Because Jameis Winston has a reputation for throwing interceptions (he has a 3.3% pick rate this year), there were many after the game blaming the loss on his turnovers.

His first pick was on a screen pass that the defender read and stepped in front of Nick Chubb. The second was him trying to get the Browns back in the contest. CBS’ Tony Romo criticized the throw (ironic because Romo forced throws), but the Browns were down 13 with just over three minutes to go.

If Winston was dinking and dunking, yes, the Browns might have scored a touchdown, but they likely would have had no time to score another.

We alluded to Winston’s interception rate earlier; did you know Joe Flacco’s rate a year ago was 3.9%? Flacco didn’t have the turnover reputation that Winston has from his days in Tampa Bay, so it wasn’t highlighted.

While we understand people who don’t want to go with Winston to start the 2025 season, we say find a better alternative. Because that won’t be easy, because of availability.

We hear a lot of rumblings about Justin Fields being available again, but frankly, we do not see that as an improvement.

Seeing what Winston could be with a viable running game would be of interest here. The Browns are the worst in the league at running the ball, and we know how important the play-action pass is to Stefanski’s offense.

We get the interceptions are an issue for Winston, but he does move the football, and that gives you a chance to win.

And we will stick to our guns about Dorian Thompson-Robinson. If you want to see him, play him in the last two games. That should cure your curiosity.

The Creative Browns Find Another Way To Lose

There are years where teams are destined to do well. They get every break. Players come out of nowhere to make positive contributions.

Conversely, there are years when everything goes wrong for a team. And that’s the only way we think you can explain the Cleveland Browns right now.

Some of it was self-fabricated, no doubt. When you finish 11-6 and make the playoffs and then replace most of your offensive coaching staff, you kind of deserve what happens to you.

It is utterly amazing to have a starting quarterback throw for 395 yards, two touchdowns, and not turn the ball over and still score just 14 points. It should have been 20 points if not for two missed field goals by Dustin Hopkins, who was 18 of 21 from beyond 40 yards a year ago, and this season has missed six kicks.

Hopkins missed a 32-yard attempt which was nullified by penalty and then missed a 27 yarder right before halftime.

There have been too many games this season where the defense played well enough to win for Cleveland, but yesterday wasn’t one of them. They were atrocious. They allowed 200 rushing yards for the second time this season, and a season high of 473 yards.

If you can’t stop the run, you can’t win. And the Browns’ defense has held opponents under 100 just twice all year.

Taysom Hill, a 34-year-old QB/TE/RB looked like someone bound for Canton. When he’s in the game, you have to figure the ball is going to him, yet Cleveland allowed him to rush for 138 yards and three touchdowns, catch eight passes for 50 yards and complete a pass for 18 more.

And he turned it over twice!

Don’t forget, besides the two missed field goals, the special teams allowed a 53-yard punt return and returned three kickoffs for an average of 18.5 yards. Cleveland hasn’t had a viable kick returner since Josh Cribbs and it shouldn’t be that difficult to find a decent one, let alone someone as dynamic as Cribbs.

The one thing we feared was a seeming lack of effort from some of the players, which could cost Kevin Stefanski his job. The optics weren’t good in New Orleans where it appeared players were going through the motions at times.

What can be done at this point in the season?

Perhaps some accountability is in order. It will be tough because of the short week before Thursday’s game vs. Pittsburgh, but the Browns will then have some time off before a Monday night game at Denver.

If players aren’t putting forth maximum effort, then they should lose playing time or a roster spot. After all, with the playoffs out of the question, shouldn’t the coaching staff and front office be looking towards next season and who can help then?

Hopefully, the players themselves will get together and put up more of a fight at home in a rivalry game in a couple of days. The thought of getting embarrassed in front of a national audience should be enough for some players.

As for the organization? It’s hard to trust them to make the correct decision heading into next season based on their actions surrounding the coaching staff and casting their lot with Deshaun Watson.

It’s a shame for the long time Browns such as Joel Bitonio, Myles Garrett, Nick Chubb, David Njoku, and Denzel Ward that what should have been a promising season has turned to garbage.

Browns Don’t Need To Tank Again

The Cleveland Browns are having a dreadful season at 2-7, and it’s probably worse because of the expectation coming into the season after a 11-6 record a year ago.

But Browns’ fans being Browns’ fans and some of the Browns’ media being people who have covered a terrible franchise over the last 20 years, the knee jerk reaction is the team should lose every game the rest of the season, because that’s the only way to win in the future. Get the highest draft position possible.

We feel differently and one of the reasons is this team isn’t that bad from a talent standpoint. Yes, they need to get younger as the Browns are one of oldest rosters in the NFL this season.

Besides, the whole “tanking” thing was done in 2015-17 when the Browns went 4-44 over three seasons. Unless we fell asleep like Rip Van Winkle, we don’t remember a Super Bowl parade after the organization did that.

Cleveland has the worst offense in the league and that was after they replaced pretty much the entire coaching staff on that side of the football. But you have to think that with competent quarterback play, the Browns would be 4-5 right now and still in the playoff hunt, rather than being among the worst teams in the league.

That said, we do believe in Bill Parcells’ adage that your record is what it says it is.

First, getting a high draft pick is no guarantee in getting a top-notch quarterback. A look at the best QBs in the sport shows that. Patrick Mahomes was the 10th overall pick. Josh Allen? 7th overall. Lamar Jackson was the 32nd pick.

Joe Burrow and Jared Goff were both selected first overall. On the other hand, another highly regarded young passer, Justin Herbert was picked sixth.

The Browns are going to have a high choice in next year’s draft, but we don’t need them to pick in the top three or five, which would mean they have to finish 3-14 or 4-13. We feel you don’t want that type of losing mentality to seep back in the locker room.

We thought the franchise was past that a year ago when they went through four quarterbacks and seemed to have the mentality that they would win anyway.

Try to get a QB next spring, but also use the rest of the picks on players who can add speed to the current roster. The Browns have 14 players currently on the team who are 30 years old or older, although two of them are specialists in K Dustin Hopkins and LS Charley Hughlett.

Of those players, the only ones who will likely be back in 2025 are Joel Bitonio and Wyatt Teller. There are nine more players will be reach 30 next season, including Nick Chubb, Myles Garrett, Ethan Pocic.

Deshaun Watson will also turn 30, but it’s difficult to see him on the roster a year from now.

The best solution might be to turn back time and rehire all of the coaches on the offensive side of the ball to give the team a functional offense again. Since that’s not possible, perhaps what’s needed is to get back to fundamentals, meaning being able to run the football.

That suits Kevin Stefanski’s offense, based on a play-action passing game. Cleveland has only allowed more than 21 points in four games this season. Designing an offense that can get to 21 points shouldn’t require a demolition of the current roster.

Browns Closing In On Extra Football.

For the people who complain about the play calling of Browns’ head coach Kevin Stefanski, last Sunday’s win over Jacksonville should dampen the criticism in this area.

On the opening drive, the Browns went with the big package on a 3rd and 1 from the Jaguars’ 34, and the latest Cleveland QB, veteran Joe Flacco, went play action and hit a wide-open David Njoku for a touchdown.

Then, in the fourth quarter on a 4th and 3, Stefanski went for it and called a short pass to David Bell on an all out blitz. Bell was wide open and basically trotted the 41 yards to the end zone to give the Browns a 28-14 lead.

So, when fans complain about a bad play call by the head coach, please remember he called those plays too.

Seriously though, this was a big win for the Browns, who go to 8-5 on the season. First, they ended a two-game losing streak. Second, this weekend also saw the other teams that came into the week at 7-5 lose, as Indianapolis, Houston, and Pittsburgh all dropped to 7-6, so Cleveland is now the fifth seed in the AFC.

The Browns’ defense got back to stopping the run, allowing just 58 yards rushing, the first time they held their opponent under 100 yards since the Arizona game (41). They also forced a season high four turnovers (tied with the Colts’ game), winning the turnover battle for just the third time this year, all resulting in victories.

While it is weird that the Cleveland defense seems dominant at home, and kind of pedestrian on the road, it is that unit that is the driving force of the team, particularly with all of the injuries at quarterback this season. And it was great to see them swarming to the ball on Sunday, even with injuries of their own.

The Browns also had four sacks, and surprisingly none by Myles Garrett, and they put pressure on Trevor Lawrence all game long.

Don’t minimize the special teams either. Corey Bojorquez had some booming punts, including a 72-yard effort from his own end zone which flipped the field for the defense. And we were a little anxious about trying a 55-yard field goal in the fourth quarter, but Dustin Hopkins, who has made a league leading 31 kicks, banged it through to give the Browns a 10-point advantage.

The Cleveland running game hasn’t been as productive recently, with only one effort of more than 100 yards in the last four contests. On the other hand, the Browns did gain their most yards offensively since the win over Baltimore in week 10.

It was also their second-best effort in terms of yardage this year, with only the 408 yards gained in the week two loss to Pittsburgh having more. Really, although people want the Browns to run it, we really don’t care about the method of moving the football as long as it gets moved.

It would be nice to cut down on the turnovers though. Cleveland leads the league in losing the football with 27 and have had only one game without giving it up. They have had five games with at least three turnovers, and not surprisingly, they are 1-4 in those games.

So, when they turn it over two times or fewer, they are a robust 7-1. We know the coaching staff isn’t emphasizing giving the ball away, and for the most part, they aren’t coming on risky plays.

However, this has to change in making a run to the playoffs.

The next opponent, Chicago, is coming in after a big home win against the Lions. The Browns have to continue to take care of business at home. If they do, their season will not end in Cincinnati on the first Sunday of the new year.

Browns Stack Another Win With Another Gritty Performance

Before the Browns started this rugged pair of games, media people and fans were saying they were hoping for a split of the contests with the Ravens and Steelers. At the time, we felt that was the difference between the fan bases between Cleveland and Pittsburgh and Baltimore.

Those folks would not accept a split, they would want to take both games.

Fortunately, the players and coaching staff don’t think like the fans because they expected two victories and they got them, winning Sunday on the last second field goal by Dustin Hopkins to beat the Steelers, 13-10, and raise the Browns’ record to 7-3.

The Browns believe they can win every game they play, mostly because of their incredible defense, which outside of Jaylen Warren’s 74 yard run (we know, Butch Davis math), held Pittsburgh to 175 yards, 3 of 14 on third down conversions, and sacked Kenny Pickett three times.

And after a rough second half where Cleveland couldn’t move the football, rookie Dorian Thompson-Robinson came alive with 1:18 remaining in the game, completing four of five throws to get the Browns into field goal range.

Overall, the rook went 24 of 43 for 165 yards, and he threw that much only because Cleveland’s vaunted running game was stymied after halftime. The Browns were held under 100 yards on the ground for only the third time this season, getting just 96 on 29 attempts.

Once again, the defense was dominant, forcing nine punts, and getting the ball back for DTR after Cleveland had to punt it away themselves with under two minutes to go.

They should have recorded safeties on Pittsburgh’s first two offensive plays, but because of the league officials’ reticence in calling the two point defensive score, neither were called. It was also the fourth game this season, Cleveland allowed less than 100 net yards passing.

In today’s NFL, that’s incredible.

It was the Browns’ fourth win by three points or less this season, but those wins are against San Francisco (7-3), Baltimore (7-3), Pittsburgh (6-4) and Indianapolis (5-5). They also have three victories by more than 20 points this season, the same as the Ravens and 49ers.

As a comparison, Kansas City has one, Miami has two, and Philadelphia, with the league’s best record, has none. So, it is not as though Cleveland is doing it with smoke and mirrors.

Apparently, the Browns will be signing veteran Joe Flacco as insurance for the rest of the season, but unless Thompson-Robinson starts to turn the ball over, our guess is he’s the starter going forward. Flacco is just there to provide professional quarterback play should something happen to DTR.

Kevin Stefanski wanted his rookie to take care of the football and for the most part, he did just that, and he put together a drive at the end to get the team in position for a game-winning field goal.

Why wouldn’t you keep him in there?

We have been a fan of the Browns for a long time, but this team has renewed our love for the team. This team plays with heart, they are physical, and they don’t make excuses. They treat each game as its own entity and views it as an opportunity to go 1-0 as their coach says.

After watching the opening win against Cincinnati and the way the defense played, we felt this team would be in every game.

It’s right there for the 2023 Cleveland Browns. They will look to go 1-0 next week at Denver.

Garrett Wills The Browns To A Road Win

If you read this web site on a regular basis or follow us on social media, you know we are very critical of the NFL officiating. We believe it is the worst in all of professional sports.

Someone on X (Twitter) made a comment that they saw Browns’ running back Duke Johnson holding the football at the bottom of a pile and an official award the ball to the opponent.

So yes, the Cleveland Browns were probably the beneficiaries of some poor calls by the officials. But they happen all around the league every week, so there is no need to feel remorse about a win on Sunday if you are a fan.

As Bill Parcells famously said, you are what your record says you are, and the Browns are 4-2 after a 39-38 win over Indianapolis on Sunday.

Even though they gave up 38 points, the story of the game was still the Cleveland defense. Over the first five games, opponents couldn’t move the football with much success, but Sunday, the Colts did move the ball, getting a handful of big plays to help them amass 456 yards.

They flipped the script because they created turnovers, four of them in fact, scored a defensive touchdown, blocked a field goal, and had the best player on the field in Myles Garrett.

Garrett’s first half was unbelievable, Lawrence Taylor-like if you will. Immediately after the pair calling the game said they hadn’t called Garrett’s name; he recorded a strip sack which led to the Browns’ second touchdown, tying the game at 14.

Next, he leaped over the offensive line to block a field goal, which Denzel Ward picked up and moved into Colts’ territory, setting up a Cleveland field goal.

Then right before halftime, he did it again, this time in the end zone and Tony Fields recovered the ball for a defensive touchdown, putting Cleveland up 24-21.

So, while the defense had its worst game of the season in terms of giving up points and yardage, it scored a touchdown directly, and set up at least 10 more points. We say at least because after the Fields score, the defense forced a three and out, setting up another Dustin Hopkins’ field goal.

Can speaking of Hopkins, how big was the trade for him before the season started? Andrew Berry knew he couldn’t go into the season with Cade York’s lack of consistency, so he acquired the veteran from San Diego.

His statistics showed he was good inside the 50 (almost 90% for his career), but so-so beyond that distance at 15 for 30.

However, he’s become a tremendous weapon for Kevin Stefanski, making 16 of 18 field goals, including 7 for 7 from 50 yards or more. He made four kicks Sunday, three from past midfield, including a career long 58 yarder.

The Browns have won two straight games without much of a passing attack, and everyone know that cannot continue. Hopefully, Deshaun Watson continues to get better and can play going forward, but he may have to change his style.

If he can’t put as much zip on the ball because of his shoulder, then he needs to make an adjustment. Plenty of quarterbacks have been successful later in their career despite losing MPH on their throws. Peyton Manning and Joe Montana come to mind.

But the offense needs to be better in the passing game for sure. We were happy to see David Njoku used more because we continue to believe he is only behind Amari Cooper in being a big play threat.

As Stefanski said last week, the Browns need to continue to stack wins, and they have another opportunity to do just that in Seattle next Sunday. It won’t be easy because the Seahawks are 4-2 and they have one of the game’s best coaches in Pete Carroll.

On the other hand, their last three wins are against Carolina, the Giants, and Cardinals.

We will bet the Cleveland defense will be much better next week.