Harbaugh Should Be Browns’ First Choice. No Question.

A few years ago, we wrote a piece about NFL head coaches and in our opinion, there are only four or five at any one time who are difference makers.

At the time, we thought those coaches were Bill Belichick, Andy Reid, Pete Carroll, Mike Tomlin, and John Harbaugh.

Belichick has moved on to college football and Carroll is now in his 70s, and we would replace them with Sean McVey and Mike Vrabel.

What we are looking at are coaches who can win in different ways, different quarterbacks, and has shown they can adapt to the constant changes of professional football.

On Tuesday, the Ravens parted ways with John Harbaugh after 18 seasons and a 180-113 regular season record, 12 playoff appearances and a Super Bowl win in 2012. He had just three losing seasons in that period, including this past season, but none of those seasons came in succession.

He won with two different quarterbacks in Joe Flacco and Lamar Jackson, and in the latter’s case, basically changed the way he ran an offense in order to suit Jackson’s skill set.

We look at Harbaugh a lot like Reid, who coached the Eagles for 14 seasons, making nine playoff appearances, including a loss in the Super Bowl. He was let go after a 4-12 season with the prevailing thought being he wore out his welcome in Philadelphia at 54-years-old.

He went to Kansas City the following season, transformed a 2-14 team into one that went 11-5 and made the playoffs. He’s won three Super Bowl in KC and actually has won more games there (149) than with the Eagles (130).

Yes, we know Harbaugh will be 64 during the early part of the 2026 season. But it appears he still has a passion for the game. We know someone who says he looks like the most beleaguered man on the planet during games, he shows his emotions on his sleeve, especially when something goes wrong for his squad.

We know the Haslams like to spend money. Heck, it took them having to guarantee a contract for them to change Deshaun Watson’s mind. So, offer Harbaugh basically a blank check to come and coach the Browns.

We believe he can be a coach who can change the culture and bring accountability and leadership to an organization that badly needs it. And if Harbaugh can work with Andrew Berry? Great. If he doesn’t want to? Find someone he can work with.

But it won’t likely happen.

We think because Berry somehow survived getting fired, he and the ownership want to continue the “collaborative” process, and that means they want someone who will work with them, that they can control, and Harbaugh might just come in have strong opinions on what needs to be done.

And frankly, we don’t know if the Browns’ hierarchy want to hear about doing things differently. That’s a big weakness in running any kind of business.

Sometimes the logical move is staring you right in the face. John Harbaugh is an excellent coach. He’s available, and the Browns are in dire need of sustained success.

At least have a conversation with him. If he doesn’t want to come here under any circumstances, that’s a different story than not being willing to change in order to get a coach of his caliber.

The Browns need a coach, and a great, proven winner is available.

In Support Of Stefanski

With the Cleveland Browns unexpected struggles this season, many in the media and fans as well have to have a scapegoat for their poor record. The easy target for their angst is head coach Kevin Stefanski.

Look, we aren’t saying Stefanski is a great coach. We also don’t think there are many great coaches in the NFL currently. The only people in charge we would put in that class are Andy Reid, John Harbaugh, and Mike Tomlin.

There are others who could ascend to that level, including Stefanski, but they aren’t there yet. But to be fair, this is the first non-competitive season for the current Cleveland coach, who has won 11 games twice, but his worst season to date was a 7-10 mark in 2022.

Stefanski is among the newer age head coaches. They are younger, didn’t play in the NFL and look more like college professors than “football guys”. Others in that category would be Mike McDaniel in Miami, Matt LaFleur in Green Bay, and Shane Steichen in Indianapolis.

There are others too.

They were hired because teams were looking for their Sean McVay, a young coach, full of energy, and a football savant. He took the league by storm at age 31, going 11-5 in his first year and taking the Rams to the Super Bowl in his second year. He won the title in his fifth season.

We think perhaps these guys don’t get a long rope from the fans because they don’t resemble the coaches they grew up with. Coaches like Vince Lombardi, Mike Ditka, Bill Parcells and Bill Cowher. Emotional men with fire in their eyes and not afraid to confront players.

We forget about people like Tom Landry, Paul Brown, and the last Browns’ coach to win a title, Blanton Collier, who were quieter and more refined on the sidelines.

Both types have had success winning in the NFL.

Another thing that irritates the hard-core football folks is Stefanski’s press conferences after games. At this point, we don’t know why anyone is surprised the coach says nothing in these settings. Our guess is he has told his players he will not do that. He will take the blame when things go bad.

To go along with this, we have no doubt errors are addressed and handled in the locker room. We don’t think players get to do whatever they want.

Usually, there is a one-year grace period for a coach after a successful season, and even though they didn’t win the Super Bowl, last year was a great season for the Browns. That would indicate Stefanski is safe this year, but a slow start in 2025 puts him firmly on a hot seat.

It does become a different story if Stefanski loses the locker room, and the players are no longer putting out an effort to win games. And that could occur if moves are made to play younger players who aren’t ready to compete.

Remember, the players don’t care about next year, nor do they care about draft picks. And that’s not just players who feel they won’t be back with the Browns next season.

Would people like Stefanski more if he got in players’ faces on the sidelines and ranted and raved at the officials? Probably, but that’s not him.

Stefanski deserves to come back next year and reverse what happened this year. Even if the losing continues unless he loses the players.

In Evaluating Stefanski, Look At All Head Coaches

The Cleveland Browns seemed to have pushed all chips to the center of the table. Over the weekend, GM Andrew Berry traded for three-time Pro Bowl DE Za’Darius Smith from the Minnesota Vikings for some mid-level draft picks.

Smith has accumulated ten or more sacks in three of the last four years, and in the one year he didn’t, he played just one game due to injury. We would seem to be a perfect complement to Myles Garrett, and also is another defensive lineman, which new defensive coordinator Jim Schwartz loves to collect.

However, the thing that most of the local media comes back to in evaluating the Browns is Kevin Stefanski, and is he a good enough coach to lead the Browns deep into the post-season.

Our opinion on coaching in the NFL is that in no other sport can coaching make as much of a difference as it does in pro football. It happens all the time. Heck, it happened to Stefanski. Don’t forget he took over a 6-10 team and went 11-5 and made the playoffs.

But we also believe there aren’t many difference makers among the head coaches in the NFL. We believe there might be five coaches who are special.

Of course, Bill Belichick is on that list. And unfortunately for the Browns, two of the other ones play in the AFC North, Pittsburgh’s Mike Tomlin and Baltimore’s John Harbaugh.

That duo has put together a “culture” that winning must be attained, and they will do everything they can, including playing non-traditional football in order to win.

Certainly, Andy Reid is one of the sport’s top coaches. His success in two different places, two Super Bowl wins, three championship game appearances, and his consistent style of staying ahead of opposing defenses put him on the list.

And that last comment about Reid is key. A lot of the coaches who make an early difference do so because they do something so one has seen before, but when opposing coaches figure out a way to combat that, and they usually do, they have nothing.

As a result, the winning ends, and they are looking for a new gig in three to four years.

So, being able to adapt is what makes a good coach in our opinion. We don’t like “system coaches”, ones who have a certain style of play and can only coach that style. We think the epitome of coaching is looking at your talent and designing a plan that gets the most out of those players.

Putting players in positions where they cannot succeed is bad coaching.

Can Stefanski someday be in the class with Reid, Tomlin, and Harbaugh? Probably not, but our point is those guys are rare finds. If the Browns make the playoffs this season, he will no doubt return for a fifth year as head coach, and likely go into his sixth season.

He has two new coordinators this season, and of course, adding Schwartz is a huge move. As for why he didn’t change defensive coordinators sooner. It’s tough to fire people you work with every day, especially for a long time.

We understand the fans and media want to be cold blooded, it’s football after all, but remember than coaches look at the games differently than fans do. They have to.

Stefanski was part of the reason the Cleveland Browns didn’t succeed last season, after all, he’s the head coach. But it is also true the players weren’t good enough, there wasn’t enough depth, and the defense wasn’t up to par.

And if they don’t make the playoffs this season, he will likely be fired and a new coach will be brought in. Unless you are in the upper echelon of head men, that’s the way the NFL works.