With the hot stove league season firmly in place, we have discussed the Cleveland Guardians’ need to help their offense, which has dropped to ninth in the American League in runs scored.
We also feel the biggest need for the team is getting hitters with the ability to avoid making outs. We understand that may sound trite, but Cleveland ranked third from the bottom in on base percentage at .303. In a nutshell, they need batters who can reach base in other ways besides getting hits.
Guardians’ hitters ranked fourth last in the AL in drawing walks a year ago, and only Jose Ramirez walked more than 50 times last season. Myles Straw drew 67 walks, but only 29 were in a Cleveland uniform.
Are there any free agents available that could help in this area. Yes, the front office could (and should) target players on the trade front who get on base as well, but we wanted to look at the players already available.
We also aren’t going to look at players who will be well outside of the price range the Guardians operate in. So, even though Kris Bryant has a .376 on base mark, we know the Cleveland front office isn’t living in an area where they could give the former Cub and Giant what he is looking for.
We would be interested in a one or two year deal for former National League MVP Andrew McCutchen, who not only gets on base, but also would solve one of the corner outfield spots.
McCutchen is 35 years old and had a 778 OPS in 2021, hitting .222 with 27 HR and 80 RBI. He did walk 81 times however, so his on base percentage was a respectable .334. If his batting average got back into the .250 range it has been over the past few years, he would be a solid addition.
Another intriguing option, although he might want big money, is Anthony Rizzo. In our opinion, the Guardians need a first baseman, and Rizzo had a .344 OBP last year and a 783 OPS, hitting 22 dingers, knocking in 61 and drawing 52 walks in his time with both the Cubs and Yankees. He has a lifetime .369 on base average.
There is also soon to be 34-year-old Tommy Pham, coming off a poor season with San Diego, in which he hit .229, but still had a .340 OBP. He also had 15 homers. The right-handed hitting Pham has a career .364 on base mark, and also has a career 810 OPS. He might be worth a one or two year deal as well.
And last is the player the Guardians have been linked to by many sources, former Oakland A’s outfield Mark Canha. He will be 33 next year, and over the last three seasons, has on gotten on base at 39.6%, 38.7%, and last year’s 35.8%, drawing a career high 77 walks.
He also has some pop, hitting 60 home runs over the past three full major league seasons.
All of these players strikeout a little more than we would like, but as long as they are drawing a good share of walks, we can live with the whiffs.
Adding one of these players would be a big help to the offense for Terry Francona’s squad, and the fact they are veterans wouldn’t hurt. The game is measured by the number of outs, and these guys do a better job of avoiding them than what the Guardians currently have.