Tribe Still Has Some Great Performers

 

As the Indians’ season plays itself out, the best the team can hope for is to play a spoilers’ role the last two months of the campaign.  What do fans have to look forward to?  A couple of months watching a few Indians having outstanding years, but also viewing the struggles of young players trying to earn major league jobs for the 2009 season.  Mix in being able to look at some prospects for the first time, and that is what the Tribe’s season has turned into as we turn the calendar to August. 

 

We know we go back and forth on Jhonny Peralta, but his recent torrid stretch has quietly made his season a very good one.  According to the VORP (Value Above Replacement Player) ranking on Baseball Prospectus.com, Peralta is the second best shortstop in the American League, behind only Texas’ Michael Young.  The much-maligned SS is now hitting .271/.312/.495 with 17 HR and 57 RBI.  We realize he is no Omar Vizquel defensively, but he is better with the glove than future Hall of Famer Derek Jeter.  And if you think I’m insane, watch some Yankee games and look at his range.  When people say the Tribe has certainty at only two positions (Sizemore in CF and Martinez at C), they are mistaken.  Jhonny Peralta will be the Cleveland shortstop next season.

 

Speaking of Sizemore, he’s another Indian having a spectacular campaign.  Besides being 2nd in the AL in home runs, he is tied for 3rd in total bases, and ranks 6th in the league in runs scored despite the Tribe offense being sub par for most of the year.  He’s hitting .279/.384/.543, which rivals the numbers he put up in 2006, when he pounded out more than 50 doubles.  In fact, he is on pace to hit 40 doubles and 40 home runs this season.  Add in 26 stolen bases, and if the Tribe were in contention, you would be looking at an MVP season for the 26-year-old gold glove outfielder. 

 

Of course, the other huge season being had by an Indian is that of lefty Cliff Lee.  Lee is the front-runner for the Cy Young Award, which would be the second in a row won by a Cleveland pitcher.  The southpaw is going for his major league leading 15th win tonight against Detroit.  He currently has a 2.29 ERA and his strikeout to walk ratio is an amazing 120:20.  Lee started the season on an unbelievable roll, and really hasn’t had any drop off.  He’s been the best pitcher in the American League all season long.

 

There is one other player to say good things about as well.  Shin-Soo Choo is hitting just .259, but half of his hits (36) are for extra bases.  He has an on-base percentage of over. 350 and a slugging percentage of over .450, which means you are a good offensive player.  It’s time to see him against some left-handed pitchers.

 

The Indians are currently 8th in the AL in runs scored, ranking 7th in slugging percentage and only 10th in on base percentage.  The extra base power has increased due to players like Choo, Kelly Shoppach (.466 slugging percentage) and Peralta, who now has 50 extra base hits on the season.  The low OBP is due to having young, impatient hitters who have had trouble working counts. 

 

Anthony Reyes made his first start at Buffalo last night, pitching five innings and allowing three runs in getting the win.  It would not be surprising to see Reyes starting here soon in place of Matt Ginter, who struggled yesterday.  Nor would it be a shock to see Zach Jackson, acquired in the Sabathia deal, in Cleveland soon.  He has put up a 1.08 ERA at Buffalo and has started his last two appearances.

 

MW

Tribe Loses Blake, Series

 

There is no truth to the rumor that Eric Wedge is leaving the Indians to become Joe Torre’s bench coach with the Dodgers to join Casey Blake in Los Angeles.  It was a busy weekend for the Indians’ front office, as they made a pair of deals to improve the future of the ballclub.  On the field, the Tribe lost two out of three to Minnesota as they continue to struggle in divisional play.  They are now 4-8 on the season against the Twins.  By the way, their next seven games are against AL Central Divisional foes.

 

Blake was dealt on Saturday to the Dodgers with the Indians getting minor leaguers Jonathan Meloan and Carlos Santana in return.  Meloan is a right-handed pitcher, who has been starting at Class AAA Las Vegas, but had a brief call up in 2007 as a reliever.  He will be moved back to the bullpen at Buffalo, and with the state of the Cleveland relief corps, could be here soon.  He is just 24 years old, and came into the year averaging 13.5 strikeouts per nine innings.  His strikeout pitch is a slider that he throws in the mid-80’s.  He was ranked as the #8 prospect in the Dodgers farm system by Baseball America.

 

Santana is a converted catcher who is currently tearing up the hitter friendly California League, batting .323/.431/.563 with 14 home runs in 350 at-bats for Inland Empire.  He has also walked more than he has struck out (69/59).  He will go to Kinston, and may be up to Akron before the season is over.  He also leads the minor leagues in RBI with 96.  He’s just 22 and a switch hitter to boot.  Mark Shapiro was able to extract two good prospects for Blake because he agreed to pay the balance of the third baseman’s contract in the deal.

 

Shapiro then took a gamble on 26-year-old right-hander Anthony Reyes, picking him up from the Cardinals for AA reliever Luis Perdomo.  Reyes started Game 1 of the 2006 World Series for the Cardinals, but has battled inconsistency and some arm troubles since.  He was regarded as St. Louis’ best prospect three or four years ago.  He throws in the mid-90’s, but is working on a sinker that he throws in the low 90’s.  He is 2-3 with a 3.25 ERA in 11 starts at Class AAA Memphis, and went 2-1 with a 4.91 ERA in 10 relief appearances with the big club.

 

For all of the criticism Shapiro takes, this is a situation he has done very well with.  He maximizes the value of guys who will be leaving for free agency at the end of a season, if the Tribe is out of it.  That may make total sense, but there are plenty of teams that don’t share that philosophy.  The GM picked up two hard throwers and a switch-hitting catcher for a player who would have brought back two amateur draft picks in return and a AA reliever.  If just one of these players becomes a key player for the Indians, then Shapiro made a great move.

 

As for the games on the field, I know the Tribe had a left on left match up in the ninth inning yesterday in a 2-2 game, but you cannot leave Justin Morneau beat you if you are playing the Twins.  Especially if you are behind in the count 3-1, as Rafael Perez was in the count, you can’t let him get the key hit with first base open.  On Friday, why not bring in Perez to start the ninth with Joe Mauer and Morneau being the first two hitters.  Instead Wedge brings in Masa Kobayashi, because he’s the closer, and after a hit and a dinger, it’s 5-4.  If you don’t have an established closer, then you play the percentages.

 

The manager and front office are taking a look at players for the rest of the season.  However, if you have a chance to win, then try to win.  Also, since the season has been scrapped, why not try some different things like letting Perez start the ninth to get two of the tougher left handed batters in the game?  One more thing…let’s not have Franklin Gutierrez hitting second anymore.  Oh, and another thing, if you have a tie game, you probably shouldn’t have David Dellucci in LF with Ben Francisco in CF.  Lose the DH and put Grady Sizemore in CF.  Francisco may have caught Casilla’s bloop to left to start the inning.

 

KM

Tribe-Angels Series Review

 

The Tribe ended their west coast trip at 3-3, losing the series to the Los Angeles Angels despite getting well-pitched games in two of the three contests.  Still, the way the Indians have played on the road this year, a .500 trip should be considered a success.  The ballclub returns home for three with the Twins over the weekend, featuring the return of Fausto Carmona, and then four more with the Tigers, the last game being played the same day as the trading deadline.  Here are thoughts on the Angels series:

 

Eric Wedge and Carl Willis should shoulder part of the blame for the 14-11 loss in the rubber game of the series.  After losing a pair of two run leads (2-0 and 4-2), there is no way Aaron Laffey should have been sent out there again once Cleveland took a 6-5 advantage.  The bullpen was rested and there was an off day on Thursday.  The skipper could have put Tom Mastny out there to start the inning, or even Jensen Lewis, and tried to get them through the sixth.  If they held the lead, the Tribe still had Edward Mujica and Masa Kobayashi to finish up.

 

I understand the staff is trying to find out about some young guys, but it doesn’t hurt anyone to try and win a game while you are doing it.  Laffey had allowed eight hits in four innings, and clearly didn’t have it.  He had already blown two leads, and if I were managing there would have been no way he would have had a chance to blow a third.  Bringing Mastny in with the bases loaded also was unfair to the young reliever, particularly since he hadn’t pitched since July 13th. 

 

Going back to looking at young guys, if this is true, then how come the manager pinch-hits for Andy Marte at pretty much every clutch situation?  I understand the young 3B has just 4 RBI’s on the season, and has struggled with men in scoring position, but any time he comes up in a last game situation with men on base, Wedge goes to the bench.  He can’t have it both ways, if the management wants to take a look at the young guys, then Marte needs to bat in clutch opportunities.

 

On the positive note, in the first two games of the series, the pitching was very good.  Paul Byrd raised his trade value by allowing just one run in 5-1/3 innings, and more importantly kept the ball in the park.  He could be an attractive piece for a National League contender looking for back of the rotation help.  Matt Ginter also threw well, allowing three runs in six innings.  It will be very hard to send the veteran back after the two outings he’s had for the Tribe.  At the very least, he’s kept his team in the game in both starts, which is better than Laffey and Sowers.  However, the management needs to make judgments on these two southpaws.

 

The situational hitting continues to be a problem.  The Indians have to lead the league in having a man on third with no one out, and not getting him in.  It happened again on Wednesday afternoon.  Either the hitters are too anxious and swing at a borderline first pitch, or they are too patient and get themselves into a hole.  Contrast that to the Angels’ hitters, who many times swung at the first pitch and hit the ground ball to the right side to move a runner.  Part of the Tribe’s problem is too many hitters are prone to the strikeout.

 

The next ten games are against Central Division contenders, Minnesota and Detroit.  The big things to look at this weekend are Cliff Lee going for win #14, and of course, the return of Carmona to the rotation.  His return may help stabilize the starting staff a little bit.

 

MW

 

Expectations are High for Browns' Fans

 

The Cleveland Indians didn’t deal with last year’s success very well, and now it’s the Cleveland Browns turn.  The Brownies narrowly missed the playoffs last season with a 10-6 record, and now many experts are projecting the brown and orange to get to the post-season for the first time since 2002.  Expectations are high in our city.  Fans expect this football team to have a very good season.  Training camp starts today so let the hype machine begin.

 

Last year, the Cleveland defense had a problem stopping the run.  So, GM Phil Savage went out and traded for defensive linemen Corey Williams from Green Bay and Shaun Rogers from Detroit to shore up the area.  He gave up cornerback Leigh Bodden and draft picks to get them, and Savage’s aggressiveness is just one more reason for football fans in Northeast Ohio to be excited.  Savage seems to understand that Browns’ fans are tired of waiting for a contender, and last season’s near miss just heightened their anticipation.

 

There is no question that the improvement of the defense is the key to a winning season.  Early last season, the unit was abysmal, but got better as the year went on.  Fortunately, the offense put up points at a rapid rate, and the Browns stole some victories.  If this year’s defense, under new coordinator Mel Tucker, can move into the top half of the league’s rankings, it should be a fun fall and winter down at the lakefront. 

 

While the line is stronger due to Savage’s acquisitions, the secondary, particularly at cornerback appears shaky.  With the trade of Bodden and the season ending injury to Davin Holly, the starters are second year men Eric Wright and Brandon McDonald.  There isn’t much depth either with veteran Terry Cousins as the nickel corner, and the fourth cornerback spot is very much up for grabs.  However, the improvement up front could lessen the load on these guys.

 

The offense should still put up points if guys like Joe Thomas, Eric Steinbach, Braylon Edwards, Kellen Winslow, and Jamal Lewis remain healthy.  Derek Anderson gets more support nationally than he does in Cleveland, but why shouldn’t he be better with a year’s experience under his belt.  And, of course, Brady Quinn is here, meaning Romeo Crennel has a good option as a back up should Anderson be a one-hit wonder.  The depth at wide receiver with Joe Jurevicius hurt, and at running back behind Lewis could be problematic, and is something to watch in the exhibition (read: pre-season) games.

 

It’s been a long time since Cleveland can feel good about its football team.  Let’s hope the Brownies have a little bit more luck than the Indians is carrying things over from last year.

 

JD

 

Thoughts On the Seattle Series

 

The Cleveland Indians came out of the All-Star break with a thud, but rebounded to take two of three in Seattle against the Mariners, who are the only team in the AL with a worse record than the Tribe.  The win on Saturday broke a 10 game road losing streak, and it was the team’s first road series win since beating the Dodgers just about a month ago.  Still, it was better than losing a series to the woeful Mariners.  Now, it’s on to Anaheim to take on the team with the best record in the American League, the Angels.

 

Cliff Lee continued his tremendous season yesterday, throwing a complete game in a 6-2 Indian victory.  The lefty is now 13-2 with a 2.29 ERA on the season.  It is amazing to me how many people talk about dealing Lee for more prospects.  Yes, he is having a career season.  However, it’s not like Lee is a stiff who is having the first good season of his career.  Remember, Lee won 18 games in 2005, and 14 games in 2004 and 2006.  He finished in the top five in the AL Cy Young Award voting in ’05, and may win the honor this year.  If you look at his statistics, it’s pretty clear that last season’s horrible record was the aberration, not this season.

 

Asdrubal Cabrera returned to the ballclub as we requested, and had hits in each game he played.  Both hits went to left-center field, which is encouraging in that the infielder is going with the pitch.  Cabrera played 2B in both games, but I think he will get some reps at shortstop with Jhonny Peralta getting some partial days rest at DH.  Jamey Carroll played well in Cabrera’s absence, and doesn’t deserve to lose all of his playing time.  Carroll could be another veteran available in a deal at the July 31st deadline.

 

It was interesting to note that one pitcher who did not appear in the series was Rafael Betancourt.  He certainly could have pitched an inning in the 8-2 loss on Friday night, but wasn’t used.  Perhaps Eric Wedge no longer feels comfortable in using the right-hander with a lead, and that is why he wasn’t used in the two victories.  Edward Mujica pitched two scoreless frames in the Saturday win, continuing his good performance.  It may be that Mujica is going to get a good look with games on the line in the second half.

 

Wedge says the Indians are staying committed to Jeremy Sowers, who did gain his first win of the season on Saturday, but early on, the southpaw was very shaky.  He got out of trouble with double plays in the first two innings, and then gave up a few loud outs while seemingly cruising through the next three innings.  With a 9-2 lead in the sixth, Sowers hit a batter, gave up a hit, and then walked a hitter, ultimately giving up two runs.   It was a win, but I don’t think anyone is counting the days until Sowers next start.  On the other hand, if they are playing for 2009, the team has to find out about the young lefty.

 

However, it was disturbing for the skipper to talk about the ballclub needing David Dellucci.  The veteran did drive in a run in Sunday’s victory, and he was in the lineup for two of the three games.  Maybe the Tribe is showcasing him, but his performance of late would only serve to lower his already ebbed trade value.  The front office has heard from pretty much everyone that they need to make other arrangements for the OF/DH.  Allowing him to take at-bats away from people this team needs to see is not a productive use of the Indians time out of contention.

 

KM

 

Signing Gibson is Good First Move

 

The Cleveland Cavaliers made their first move of the off-season by re-signing guard Daniel Gibson to a five-year contract extension yesterday.  Gibson showed a lot of improvement from his rookie season by averaging slightly over 10 points per game.  Unfortunately for Boobie, he hurt his ankle just as he seemed to be hitting his stride at the All-Star break, gaining MVP honors in the Rookie Game, and finishing second in the three point shootout.  He then separated his shoulder in Game 5 of the Celtic series, thus missing the last two games of that round.

 

We will never know how much a healthy Gibson would have impacted the second half of the season.  Besides fitting in the new players who came in the mega-deal at the deadline, Mike Brown had to find ways to get Gibson make in playing shape so he could help in the playoffs.  You may remember the second year guard struggled mightily upon his return, but the coach stuck to his guns because he understood how important Gibson’s outside shooting is to the wine and gold offense.

 

Although this is the first move by GM Danny Ferry, it probably won’t be the last.  Remember, this team is still better than the one that went to the NBA Finals after the 2006-07 as a result of acquiring Ben Wallace, Joe Smith, Delonte West, and Wally Szczerbiak.  First round draft pick, J.J. Hickson has shown promise in summer league action, showing a good low post game.  However, his minutes will depend on how quickly he picks up Brown’s defensive concepts.  On Mike Brown’s squad, if you can’t defend, it is tough to get playing time. 

 

If he develops, Hickson could be the young blood the team is looking for in the frontcourt.  It appears the front office can’t wait for that date in December when Anderson Varajao loses his ability to veto a trade, so they can unload him as soon as possible.  Remember that Zydrunas Ilgauskas, Wallace, and Smith are all on the wrong side of 30, and of course, all are a year older than they were last season.  It is doubtful the Cavs can count on the same amount of production from this trio in the upcoming season.

 

Ferry still needs to get another player who can put the ball in the basket on a consistent basis, and it would be golden if that person could also create his own shot.  Remember, the wine and gold have a lot of money tied up in the expiring contracts of Szczerbiak, Eric Snow, and Damon Jones.  The bad part about that is those guys won’t be real attractive until the trading deadline, and the Cavs can’t wait until then.  They can’t have another season where they are worried about jelling with 25-30 games remaining on the schedule. 

 

All in all, keeping Boobie Gibson is a very good move by the front office.  Ferry must do the same with West, because he has turned out to be the key player in the trade.  However, the GM cannot stop there.  The Cavs still need another all-star type player.  Ferry knows this as well.  Don’t be surprised if another move is made before training camp starts in early October.

 

JK

What I Want to See in the Second Half

 

It appears that the traditional three-day All Star break is all but gone.  Tomorrow, the Tigers and Orioles will play the only game in the American League.  The rest of the league gets back to work on Friday, including the Indians who will start a three game series against the Seattle Mariners, and then travel to Anaheim for a set against the Angels. 

 

Even though the Tribe has played 94 games, the All-Star break is the traditional half waypoint of the season.  Here are some things I would like to see the rest of the year, and see them sooner than later.

 

Bring Asdrubal Back.  Since being sent to Buffalo, Asdrubal Cabrera has hit .326/.375/.475 with 4 HR and 13 RBI.  Because the Indians are looking ahead to 2009, it’s time to bring him back to Cleveland and play him everyday at 2B.  The Tribe can designate journeyman utility man Jorge Velandia for assignment.  While I would like to see Cabrera take more walks (only 7 in 141 at bats at AAA), it looks like he has regained his hitting stroke.  The Indians need to see if Cabrera can hit enough to play everyday at the major league level.

 

Put La Porta on the Fast Track.  Matt La Porta is the guy GM Mark Shapiro wanted in the CC Sabathia deal, and it is obvious he has mastered the AA level.  He has hit .292/.401/.575 with 21 HR and 70 RBI in 318 at bats.  Let’s move him to Buffalo and see what he can do at the AAA level.  It’s not as though the Bison outfield is loaded with prospects.  He would be replacing guys like Jason Tyner, Jason Cooper, Todd Linden, and Brad Snyder.  It would set the slugging outfielder up for a promotion to the big club perhaps as early as mid-August.  There is no need for him to stay at Akron.

 

Trade Casey Blake.  Blake has been a solid performer since he came to the Tribe in 2003, even though he seems to be a lightning rod for the fans.  However, he is making $6 million per year and with the season he is having, would likely want more next season.  That being said, he will be 35 years old next season and is unlikely to be better in ’09.  He can do a solid job at 1B, 3B, LF, and RF, and is a solid major league hitter.  Mark Shapiro needs to get what he can for Blake, and give him the chance to play for a contender.  His departure would also give an opportunity to see Andy Marte and/or Wes Hodges at 3B the rest of the season.

 

Look At Some Kids.  Besides the aforementioned La Porta and Hodges, the Indians should give some big league time to guys like reliever Jeff Stevens (let’s give him a shot to close), OF Trevor Crowe (if he ever gets healthy), 1B Jordan Brown, RP Tony Sipp (just back after Tommy John surgery) and even lefty Zach Jackson, who was in the Sabathia deal.  This team cannot waste time giving more at bats to guys like David Dellucci. 

 

Get Healthy.  It looks like Fausto Carmona will rejoin the starting rotation next week when the team comes home from the west coast.  Hopefully, the Victor Martinez that returns in August will resemble the guy who played here last season.  And it would really be great if Travis Hafner could get some at bats before the season ends, so the management can see if he can show signs of getting back to a guy who can hit 30 HR in 2009.

 

Hopefully, some of these moves can occur before the season resumes in Seattle Friday night.  If the Cleveland Indians are in re-tooling mode, there isn’t any reason not to start the process as soon as possible.

 

MW

Proof That Baseball Is A Weird Game

 

If you want more proof that baseball is a funny game, look no further than the Indians four game sweep over the Tampa Bay Rays this weekend.  The Tribe came into the series on a 10 game losing streak, and the Rays had the league’s best record.  Cleveland has a journeyman just up from the minor leagues (Matt Ginter) and a guy who hadn’t won a big league game all year (Jeremy Sowers) pitching the last two games of the series, yet won both games.  Weird, indeed!

 

Want more proof?  Look at SS Jhonny Peralta.  Peralta was struggling all season long at the plate.  His strike zone judgment regressed, his batting average was in the .220 range, and he couldn’t seem to get a hit with a man on base.  For some reason, Eric Wedge decided to put him into the clean up spot in the batting order.  Since that move has been made, Peralta has torn the cover off the ball.  Over the last 30 days, the SS is batting .340 with 5 HR’s and 24 RBI.  He’s raised his batting average to .261, and his OPS is approaching 800, which is above average league wide.  Very, very strange.

 

At the end of May, the Indians’ offense was killing them.  The pitching was very good; particularly the starters, but the offense just couldn’t score runs.  When June 1st hit, the hitting started to pick up, but the pitching went south, especially the bullpen.  Since that date, Joe Borowski has been released, Rafael Betancourt has had several meltdowns, and the shuttle back and forth to Buffalo has been in full force.  In the eight game road trip, in which the Tribe went winless, the bullpen was particularly bad.  So…

 

The Indians come home, and all of a sudden the relief corps picked it up.  Only newcomer Juan Rincon gave up a run in the four game series, and the bullpen contributed three shutout innings in each of the first two games against the Rays, and came up with five scoreless frames on Sunday.  If not for Rincon and his inability to throw strikes, the relief crew would have worked a clean series against Tampa Bay.  A big contributor has been Edward Mujica, who after his horrible outing against San Diego June 14th, has not allowed a run.  Not exactly something anyone would have predicted.

 

Even Ryan Garko got into the swing of things in the series.  The right-handed hitter has been mired in all sorts of slumps since the beginning of May, but he hammered a two run dinger and a three run double Saturday night against Matt Garza.  And Franklin Gutierrez came out of an 0 for 32 slump with hits in back to back games.  Andy Marte even slugged his first home run of the year. 

 

Some things though went according to form, though.  Cliff Lee threw six scoreless innings on Friday night to win his 12th game before he goes to New York for the All Star Game.  The Tribe’s other all-star, Grady Sizemore belted his league leading 23rd homer on Saturday.  Aaron Laffey pitched well in the series opener.  And more good news…Matt La Porta belted a game winning two run home run for Akron on Friday night, his first long ball with the Indians’ organization.

 

Good luck to Sizemore and Lee this week, and here’ hoping the good play continues in Seattle on Friday night.  Also, here’s hoping Fausto Carmona shows he is healthy tonight in his first rehab assignment with Lake County, so he can be back in the rotation sometime next week.

 

KM

 

A Letter to Paul Dolan

 
The day after the Cleveland Indians traded last year’s Cy Young Award winner, CC Sabathia to the Milwaukee Brewers, I received a letter from the team’s President, Paul Dolan, explaining the trade to his franchise’s fans.  The letter was barely read when it arrived.  A couple of days later, I decided to give it a good read.  My first reaction was correct, I should have ignored it.  Then, I decided I should respond. 
 
Dear Mr. Dolan:
 
     I received your letter explaining your recent personnel decisions, including trading C.C. Sabathia.  I would advise you to save the paper in the future.  Your fans don’t want to hear about how you tried to sign the big left-hander, nor do they want to hear about the injuries to Victor Martinez, Travis Hafner, and Fausto Carmona.  Injuries are part of the game and so is free agency. 
 
     As fans, we know you wanted to sign Sabathia, but if he wanted a six or seven year deal, it’s not a good business decision for any franchise, let alone one in a mid-sized market.  However, that doesn’t make our disappointment any less.  The Indians missed the World Series, a Series they likely would have one, by one game last fall.  We were hoping this was the year the Tribe would bring home Cleveland’s first championship in 44 years.  Instead, we are watching a team that will be trying to lose less than 90 games this season.
 
     I understand that many of the fans of the Indians feel you are frugal, and do not want to spend money.  I do not share that opinion.  You invested a great deal of cash in Hafner and Jake Westbrook, as well as poured capital into the farm system.  I’m sure many people want you to throw around cash like a drunken sailor, but that doesn’t guarantee success.  The Indians haven’t won a title under your ownership, but they have made the playoffs twice, and missed two other appearances by one game apiece.  So, the Dolan regime has not been a failure.
 
    However, as fans, we don’t want letters covering your rear end.  We don’t want any more excuses.  Your father told us he wanted to win multiple titles, and I don’t doubt that the both of you have that desire.  We just want to see progress toward that end.  You have admitted that this season has not been one of progress, and dealing one of the best pitchers in baseball doesn’t seem like an end to that goal. 
 
    The letter seemed to be an immediate response to make us feel bad for your situation.  Perhaps a better reaction next time is to wait until the end of the season, so you can explain the reasons why the campaign went the way it did.  The letter sounded like a little kid whose first reaction was "I didn’t do it".  We are all Indians’ fans, and we likely will be for life.  If we could survive the teams of the 60’s, 70’s, and 80’s, we can handle a trade that was made to avoid losing an elite player for amateur draft picks.
 
Sincerely,
 
An Indians Fan for over 40 years.
 
MW
 

More Thoughts on the Trade

 

It was quite a contrast last night.  In Milwaukee, CC Sabathia received a hero’s welcome as he won his debut with the Brewers.  In Detroit, his former teammates got a Casey Blake double and a Jhonny Peralta home run in the first to take a 2-0 lead.  Unfortunately, those would be the only hits the Tribe mustered in a 9-2 shellacking at the hands of the Tigers.  Get ready for more tough times ahead with Paul Byrd serving up homers tonight, and apparently minor league veteran Matt Ginter will pitch for Cleveland against the Rays on Saturday.  Ouch!

 

That being said, here are some more thoughts on Monday’s big deal. 

 

The Key to the Deal.  Yes, Matt La Porta provides a much needed power bat to the organization, but in many ways, the key to the trade is Fausto Carmona.  Before he injured his hip, Carmona had an inconsistent 2008 season, walking more hitters than he struck out (38/23).  The fact that he had an ERA of 3.10 despite these control problems is a testament to how good his stuff is.  If the right-hander can throw strikes, he would replace Sabathia as the ace of the staff, with Cliff Lee as the #2 starter going into next season.  The Tribe needs a Fausto Carmona closer to the 2007 model than the 2008 pitcher.

 

Scouting Problems.  The deal underscores the problem the Indians’ scouting department has had since the turn of the century.  They have been unable to draft a productive hitter.   Last year’s #1 choice, Beau Mills is hitting pretty well at Kinston (.276/.361/.492) with 41 extra base hits in 83 games.  Another left handed hitter at Kinston, Nick Weglarz, just 20 years old, also shows promise (.272/.398/.449).  However, both are 1B/LF/DH types.   3B Wes Hodges is doing well at Akron, and hopefully we will see him in Cleveland before the season ends.  However, there isn’t much at AAA Buffalo, outside of another left-handed hitter, 1B Jordan Brown.  Obviously, the need for a right-handed power hitter was dire for the Tribe.

 

Let’s Be Aggressive.  Watching the Red Sox’ game the other night, made me think that Jonathon Papelbon would never have been given the job as Tribe closer as a rookie.  According to the Indians’ thinking, you have to have a veteran in that spot.  Why?  Here’s hoping La Porta is moved to Buffalo after a good week at Akron, and then up to the big club if he has a couple of good weeks at the AAA level.  There is no reason to hold him back.  Also, let’s take a look at Hodges, and some more pitchers such as Jeff Stevens.  Why not give Stevens a shot at closing?  He might just do the job.

 

It Should Have Been Us Last Year.  The Brewers made the bold move the Indians should have made last season.  The Tribe did pick up Kenny Lofton to replace an injured David Dellucci, but Mark Teixeira was on the block, but the Indians didn’t pursue him.  Would they have won the World Series by making a deal for the slugging 1B?  Maybe not, but perhaps they would have.  The Indians are hesitant to deal prospects, but the players the Rangers would have wanted would have been guys like Adam Miller (now injured), Ryan Garko (struggling), and Ben Francisco (an okay player).  Over estimating their minor league talent is a definite problem for this organization.

 

The Heat Has Been Turned Up.  Ryan Garko, Ben Francisco, and Shin-Soo Choo should have a little more pep in their step today.  Matt La Porta was brought in because these guys have been less than overwhelming.  They have been handed regular jobs, but haven’t taken advantage.  Garko in particular has been a huge disappointment after solid seasons in 2006 and 2007.

 

The Indians need to give us a reason to watch them the rest of the season.  Trotting out Jeremy Sowers every fifth day doesn’t do it.  Neither does penciling Dellucci in at the DH spot.  If Mark Shapiro is serious in having a contending club in 2009, he needs to find out about some young players, and why not try something different by using some youngsters. 

 

KM