Category: Cleveland Sports
Battles for Tribe Roster Spots
Spring training has a little bit over two weeks to go, and the first roster cuts have already been made by the Cleveland Indians. No one figured that Kelvin De La Cruz and last year’s first round draft pick Alex White were going to make the team anyway.
However, the roster is starting to take shape. The main battles going into camp were in the starting rotation and on the bench. Here is a status report—
Starting rotation. Jake Westbrook looked good against the Giants on Tuesday, and Fausto Carmona had a good outing against the Angels last week. Justin Masterson has held his spot with three solid outings. He appears to have a better changeup, which he is using against left-handed hitters. He has fanned 12 hitters in seven innings, a much-needed attribute on a starting staff that needs some swing and miss hurlers.
David Huff has been good twice and bad once, and so has Aaron Laffey. Another bad outing might change their status.
However, the surprise thus far has been righty Mitch Talbot, picked up from Tampa in the Kelly Shoppach deal. Talbot has made three appearances and has allowed just one run in eight innings with no walks and six strikeouts. He may force his way into the rotation with Laffey going to the bullpen.
Bullpen. Five of the seven spots are etched in stone barring injuries: Kerry Wood, Chris Perez, Rafael Perez, Tony Sipp, and Joe Smith are locks, in spite of Smith’s struggles during camp.
Rule 5 draftee Hector Ambriz developed an injury, conveniently, so he likely will begin the season stashed on the disabled list. The guess here is the loser in the starting rotation battle will go to the ‘pen as well, so that leaves one spot left with the main contenders being Jensen Lewis, Jess Todd, Saul Rivera, and Jamie Wright.
Our opinion is that Lewis should be tried as a starter because of his propensity to give up the long ball, which is a killer for a reliever. Wright is a journeyman with a long history of stinking in the big leagues. Todd has struggled thus far, allowing three runs in 3-1/3 frames. That would leave Rivera, who pitched for Manny Acta in Washington, or a perhaps an extended look for youngster Josh Judy, who pitching in AA Akron last season.
Bench. Although the Indians maintain that 1B Russell Branyan will be able to play the last week of spring training and therefore can start the season, his lingering absence opens the door for Michael Brantley to claim the LF job, with Matt LaPorta at first base.
Branyan’s injury puts the rest of the bench in flux. Mike Redmond will most definitely be the back up catcher to Lou Marson, who will likely win the starting nod. Mark Grudzielanek looks like he will be the reserve infielder, although it will be interesting to see when he will get some reps at 3B. If Asdrubal Cabrera needs a rest, Luis Valbuena will probably move to shortstop.
That is, unless Brian Bixler takes one of the two remaining roster spots. Bixler is a SS by trade, and the Tribe is using him all over the diamond, including the outfield in order to increase his versatility. Bixler has been in 11 games already with 16 at bats. His weakness is his bat, as he has struggling with the stick in the big leagues. He has four hits in camp, all singles.
If Bixler isn’t on the roster, his spot will likely go to Andy Marte, who can play 1B or 3B, and adds a right-handed bat. Marte is 4 for 18 thus far in exhibition games.
NOTE: Bixler was designated for assignment shortly after this was published. The Tribe claimed INF Anderson Hernandez from the Mets. Hernandez is a switch hitter who played 2B, SS, and the outfield for New York last season. He hit .251 with 3HR’s in 2009. He’s a better hitter from the right side, so he could be a platoon partner with Luis Valbuena, which would also put Grudzielanek’s spot in jeopardy.
The last spot will be between Trevor Crowe and Austin Kearns. The management would probably like Crowe to play everyday in AAA Columbus, but Kearns hasn’t recovered the batting prowess he had at the beginning of his career in Cincinnati. His only offensive strength nowadays is his ability to take a walk. He’s currently 3 for 16 with one extra base hit.
Crowe is 5 for 15 with four runs batted in and two walks in his action in Arizona. He has speed and is a good outfielder. Right now, it would seem that it’s his job to lose.
There’s a lot of action left in training camp, but watch who is playing and who isn’t. That usually tells you whom the organization wants to make the 25 man roster come Opening Day.
MW
C'mon Browns' Fans!
Early Good Signs in Arizona
The Cleveland Indians have turned into a spring training juggernaut, winning their first five games. Seriously, it’s better than losing these games, but there are always teams who dazzle people in spring training, but stink in the regular season.
However, there are some things that stand out after the first week of exhibition play.
First, new manager Manny Acta is a breath of fresh air. He doesn’t carry the somber, serious tone in talking to the media as his predecessor did. He jokes with the players and keeps the atmosphere loose. He probably will need to drop the hammer before the camp ends, and he definitely will have to during the season, but it’s nice to show that it’s a game that these men are playing.
Second, Grady Sizemore is healthy. Last season, Sizemore was plagued by a nagging groin and elbow problems, and these issues were taken care of in the off-season.
It seems people have forgotten what a tremendous player he is because of last year’s injuries. Remember, this is a guy who had an MVP type season in 2006 at age 23. He’s been the Tribe’s regular centerfielder since 2005, meaning this will be his 6th year as a starter. Yet, he will turn just 28 during the season. He’s a three time all star.
Having him back in the lineup on a regular basis will be a huge help for the Indians.
A third good early sign is the play of Michael Brantley. Apparently, the young outfielder took the news of Russell Branyan’s signing personally, and has decided to make it very difficult for Acta to send him to Columbus next month.
Brantley has reached base in seven of his 16 plate appearances (5 hits and 2 walks), and has yet to strikeout, a skill greatly needed on the 2010 Indians. He also has two extra base hits, which was a concern because he needs to show he can drive the ball. It’s only 16 at bats, but it’s good to see how Brantley responded to a challenge.
The other young Indian to make an early impact with the bat is Wes Hodges, who has been moved to the organization’s most popular position, 1B. This move is merited because Hodges had some problems defensively.
He will most definitely start the year in Columbus, but he’s had six hits in his first 11 at-bats, with three doubles and four runs knocked in.
Remember, pitchers likely aren’t throwing a lot of breaking stuff, so you have to look at hitting stats with a jaundiced eye, but both of these guys are making fans notice early in camp.
KM
Quarterback Change…More to Come?
The winds of change are blowing through the Cleveland Browns complex, and it includes the quarterback position. The team acquired QB Seneca Wallace from Seattle for an undisclosed 2011 draft pick. Now that Mike Holmgren traded for a guy who played the most important position in the game for him during his tenure with the Seahawks, it’s obvious someone is leaving.
Or should I say “someones”?
In a corresponding move, the team released Derek Anderson. That move was very much expected. However, Wallace’s arrival probably means that Brady Quinn will be joining him in leaving the organization before the 2010 season starts.
Holmgren obviously brought Wallace in because he wanted someone who was familiar with his offense. He also will be looking to bring in another signal caller to develop in the upcoming NFL draft. Whether or not that’s the guy who will be the Cleveland quarterback of the future will be determined.
It is doubtful the organization will bring Quinn back as a back up to Wallace, just as it is doubtful that Wallace is being brought in to back up the less experienced former first round draft pick.
The former Iowa State star is 29 years old, and has made 12 NFL starts, winning five of them. He’s completed 60% of his 556 pro passes, with 25 touchdown tosses and 14 interceptions.
Quinn is 25 years old, and has made 11 NFL starts, winning just three of them. He’s completed just 52% of his 353 career throws, with 10 touchdowns and nine interceptions.
Note the completion percentages. The hallmark of the west coast offense is accuracy. There is no question Wallace is the more accurate quarterback.
Before you start to use the excuse of the Browns’ feeble offensive game plans, keep in mind that last season, the Seahawks offense wasn’t great in 2008, a season in which Wallace made eight starts. However, Wallace’s record as a starter that season was 3-5. Seattle’s record in games he didn’t start? 1-7.
Quite simply, Wallace has been a more productive player than Quinn when he has had the opportunity.
Quinn’s unfamiliarity with the new offense will put him behind Wallace in the mini-camps, that’s the reason the former Irish star will be likely be gone before long.
However, if The Big Show can get another experienced quarterback to run the offense, then Wallace becomes a perfect back up and a mentor to whatever rookie is drafted as the future at the position. Quinn couldn’t do that job if the roles were reversed, and it’s fairly obvious Holmgren doesn’t think Quinn can win as a starter.
As for Anderson, he was the victim of two horrible seasons after his Pro Bowl season of 2007. He simply could never regain the magic he had early that season. After the first half of the Steelers’ game in Pittsburgh that season, the Steelers took away the deep ball and DA could never adjust.
It’s better for him to go elsewhere and jump-start his career.
JD
Things That Are Bugging Us
Holmgren & Heckert Go To Work
Tribe Needs Change in Philosophy
In the 1990’s, the Cleveland Indians may have been the model franchise in major league baseball. They had a brand new ballpark and a progressive general manager in John Hart. It was Hart that started the practice of signing young players to multi-year contracts to control costs.
They produced tons of great young players, guys such as Manny Ramirez, Jim Thome, Albert Belle, Brian Giles, Sean Casey, etc. They also traded for several minor leaguers who turned out to be stars, like Kenny Lofton, Sandy Alomar Jr., and Carlos Baerga.
They took some gambles because they were an aggressive, progressive organization.
Things couldn’t be any more different today.
Although the current administration under GM Mark Shapiro has done a good job judging talent from other organizations (Shin-Soo Choo, Asdrubal Cabrera, Carlos Santana), in other areas they have become a very conservative group, with an eye always on the balance sheet.
They put an emphasis on college players in the amateur draft, one, because they are easier to sign because they don’t have the option of going to college, and two, because they enter the Tribe system at a later age, they are at the peak of their career before they are eligible for free agency.
For example, if they sign at age 22, and play three years in the minors, the player arrives in the big leagues at 25, two years before the 27-29 years of age that has proven to be the prime years for a player. Since you have to spend six years in the majors before becoming a free agent, the player is locked with the Indians until he’s 31 years old.
Unfortunately, the best players should be getting to the big club at around 22-23 years of age. Look at Grady Sizemore for example. Sizemore was a regular at age 22, and was a star at age 23. He won’t turn 28 until this August, meaning he’s in his prime right now.
How many people realize that Sizemore is actually a month younger than his outfield cohort, Shin-Soo Choo? Choo is coming off his first very good season in the major leagues, while Sizemore has been a regular for five seasons, and has made three all-star appearances.
This is also an organization very conservative when it comes to young players. Carlos Santana is one of baseball’s best prospects and plays a position where the Indians have no clear-cut starter. Lou Marson is the favorite to open the season behind the plate with veteran Mike Redmond backing him up. However, Marson is actually two months younger than Santana.
Why is the Tribe retarding the development of Santana, especially since they are not really a contending ballclub?
The switch-hitting Santana, acquired in the Casey Blake trade with the Dodgers, should be considered a good candidate to make the 2010 Tribe out of spring training. Why isn’t the current regime willing to take a chance on someone who showed he is a plus offensive player at Class AA Akron last season?
The same head scratching occurs with the signing of free agent Russell Branyan. Branyan is a mediocre player at best, and although many are worried he is blocking Michael Brantley, he is really hurting the chances of Jordan Brown, who has won two minor league batting titles in the past three years.
Brown, 26, is a .308 lifetime hitter in the minor leagues. He’s had an OPS of over 800 three of the last four years, including a career high 913 at Columbus last season. He’s not a big power guy, but did have a slugging percentage of .532 last season. And in a rarity on the Tribe, he doesn’t strike out a lot.
Basically, he can flat out hit.
Some would pooh-pooh his statistics because they were done in the minors, but minor league performance is an indicator of how a player will do in the majors. Once again, for an organization looking to the future, why not give Brown a chance to show what he can do?
This is why it will be interesting to see what happens in spring training if a top prospect performs very well. Already, indications are the Tribe will take the safe path, and send the player down for more “seasoning”. As a benefit, the Indians also delay the players’ arbitration clock, which is beneficial…you guessed it, financially.
Small market teams need to take some risks, both in terms of money and in terms of player development. The most risky thing this franchise does is trading the few starts they have for more prospects, thus forfeiting the chance to win.
It’s time to change that philosophy. Give the young players a chance. Draft high ceiling players. If the Indians want to return to the franchise they had in the 90’s, they can’t continue down the path they are on.
MW
Cavs Using Needed Depth
The news was released yesterday that Shaquille O’Neal would likely miss the balance of the regular season with a thumb injury that requires surgery. The operation will occur today. What this means for the Cavaliers is once again they will have to use the depth they’ve accumulated over the past year.
Anderson Varajao will log a majority of minutes at center, at least until Zydrunas Ilgauskas’ likely return to the roster on March 22nd. With “Wild Thing” playing the pivot, it means more time at power forward has opened up for newly acquired Antawn Jamison, and also the reduced time for J.J. Hickson will be put on the back burner.
It also makes the pick up of recently activated Leon Powe more important because he will get time up front as well.
O’Neal provided a huge low post presence on offense, but the guy who Mike Brown will replace him with will be just as dangerous near the basket. Because the player who will become the new go to guy in the low post will be LeBron James.
Just as James took over point guard duties because of injuries to Mo Williams and Delonte West, he will replace O’Neal in the post. This is just another reason why James will be named the MVP of the NBA for the second consecutive season.
It’s reminiscent of the Lakers’ Magic Johnson playing center in the NBA Finals against Philadelphia when Kareem Adbul-Jabbar went down with a leg injury. It’s also another reason why James is more like Johnson as a player than Michael Jordan.
The difference here is it’s not just a one game thing for LBJ.
Offensively, the wine and gold will try to run more and use their athleticism to create easy baskets. But, if and when they need a hoop late in the fourth quarter, they will go inside and James will be the primary option. Jamison will get looks there as well because he is very creative near the basket, but LBJ is the first look.
Defensively is where the Cavs will miss Shaq most of all, especially with Ilgauskas still on the sidelines. Cleveland is one of the league’s best teams in terms of least points allowed in the paint, much of it due to O’Neal. You can still see Dwyane Wade driving to the rim against the Cavs and seeing him bounce off Shaq. That’s the defensive presence of O’Neal.
Between the size of Shaq and the length of Ilgauskas, it was a deterrent to opponents trying to attack the basket. That’s gone for the time being.
It would not be surprising to see Darnell Jackson get some minutes to provide some of the bulk missing from the Cavs’ lineup. However, no one comes close to providing the enormousness of Shaquille O’Neal.
This is another case of the depth of the Cavaliers paying dividends. Jamario Moon missed some time in January. Mo Williams and Delonte West missed a great deal of time, yet Daniel Gibson was ready to fill in. Actually, Shaq also missed some time with a shoulder problem early in the season, but Ilgauskas was there to fill in. That’s why the team was put together in this manner.
Before any panic sets in, remember that the reason GM Danny Ferry picked up O’Neal was to combat Dwight Howard with Orlando, and the size of the Los Angeles Lakers. It’s worked because the wine and gold is 4-1 against those two teams.
However, with a six game bulge in the conference standings, the one remaining game against the Magic isn’t going to make a difference in the regular season. If the big man returns and can play in the playoffs, particularly against those two teams (assuming the Cavs get that far), then there is no need to worry. Actually, you will probably get a fresher Shaq at that point.
JK