Guardians Without Alternatives With Bats At AAA

The good news is the Cleveland Guardians are sitting at 21-15 and have the third best record in the American League, behind only Detroit and Seattle.

The bad news is based on the number of runs they’ve scored and allowed, their record should be 16-20.

The good news is their offense is right at the league average, scoring 4.14 runs per game.

The bad news is they still have only four hitters in their lineup with OPS over 750.

The good news is the performance of Daniel Schneemann to date. The second-year big leaguer, who got off to a terrible start going 1 for his first 19, is currently red hot. He’s hitting .383 over his last 49 at bats and has a 956 OPS with five homers and 10 extra base hits.

Couple this with Angel Martinez, who also didn’t make the team out of spring training, but since his call up has batted .316 (724 OPS) and has handled centerfield for the most part very well.

On the flip side, there are a number of players struggling mightily. Brayan Rocchio, who looked like he turned a corner in the playoffs last season, is in a dreadful slump and hasn’t had a hit since April 26th and his OPS has slipped to 452.

Another post-season hero, Jhonkensy Noel, had a big pinch hit in the doubleheader Tuesday, but overall is batting just .174 with a 484 OPS and has fanned 21 times in 72 plate appearances and has walked just twice.

Rookie Will Wilson is another Guardians’ bench guy and frankly, we wonder why he’s in the major leagues. He’s hit .235 during his time in AAA, and that includes his hot start in Columbus where he started 22 for 68.

Outside of his time in the capital city, there is nothing to suggest he can hit, let alone big-league pitching. Since his call up to the big club, he’s 3 for 18 and the hits are all singles.

It is quite likely the only reason Rocchio, Noel, and Wilson are still on the 26-man roster is there are no alternatives to note in AAA.

We all know about Chase DeLauter’s injury at the beginning of training camp, but recently another top prospect, Juan Brito went down with a thumb injury that required surgery. He was batting .291 with an 891 OPS and more walks than strikeouts when he went down.

If Will Brennan was a right-handed hitter, he likely would be in Cleveland in place of Noel, but he’s not, and when he was here, he’s been shown to be a singles hitter who doesn’t walk. His slugging percentage is .442 in AAA but has walked just six times.

Perhaps another look at Johnathan Rodriguez should be in the cards, but this time with him getting Noel’s at bats. In both of his stints in the majors, he’s received very sporadic playing time, going 4 for 36.

C. J. Kayfus was just moved up to Columbus after starting the season at Akron and has played only five games at AAA. We doubt the front office will call him up any time soon.

Another problem with the roster construction is Steven Vogt’s reluctance to play Kyle Manzardo at 1B when he is DHing Steven Kwan or Jose Ramirez. Manzardo leads the team in RBIs and is third in OPS, ahead of Ramirez right now.

Yet, he’s not in the lineup when Kwan or Ramirez have a “half day” off. Why doesn’t Manzardo play and Carlos Santana, who is 39 years old, get a day off?

We say it all the time, front office people have to prepare for when things go wrong. The lack of organizational depth is telling for the Guardians.

How much longer than they overcome it? We hope until October.

Losing Game One, Cavs Need To Respond Tonight

We told everyone it wouldn’t be easy.

There is a lot of angst over the Cavaliers’ loss in game one to the Indiana Pacers, but for us, that feeling of deep concern won’t take hold unless they lose tonight to go down 0-2 in the seven-game series.

We hate to break things down in the first game to the NBA being a “make or miss league”, but that’s a good place to start. The Pacers made 53% of their three-point shots and the Cavs, the second-best team in the NBA in three-point field goal percentage, made just 9 for 38 shots from beyond the arc.

There was a 30-point difference from three between the two games. It’s tough to win when you shoot poorly and the other team is hot.

Aaron Nesmith is a very good three-point shooter, making 43% in the regular season and he knocked down four of six, but Andrew Nembhard hit five of six, and he’s a 29% shooter during the 82-game schedule.

Conversely, Donovan Mitchell (36.8%) and Max Strus (38.6%) combined to hit just 3 of 19 shots from distance.

Besides missing shots, the other troubling thing about the wine and gold’s offense was the 50 shots (out of 98) taken by Mitchell and Ty Jerome. The only other Cleveland player who took more than 10 shots was Evan Mobley, who went 9 for 13 from the floor.

The shooting was a big part of the reason for the loss, but certainly not the only reason. The Pacers definitely played with more physicality, and remember they went to the conference finals last season, they have more playoff experience than Cleveland, and it showed.

The Cavs have to pick it up in terms of physical play, and this is something we feel this group needs to reminded of constantly.

Also, Kenny Atkinson loves to talk about the depth of the Cavs and during the regular season and in round one, he was right. However, Sunday night, Indiana had five bench players score, led by Bennedict Mathurin with 11.

The wine and gold had just three bench players score, but to be fair, Sam Merrill started in place of the injured Darius Garland. Jerome and De’Andre Hunter both scored in double figures, but the only other bench points were from Isaac Okoro, who had a bucket.

We thought Okoro was effective in the first half. He was a +6 and hit a layup and had two assists and two rebounds. He didn’t do much in the second half. But in the second half, it seemed he was cast as a three-point shooter, something he’s not good at. He’s much better when he attacks the basket.

Wade is another solid defender, but didn’t even attempt a shot in the first half. In the second half he missed two shots, including a wide open three which would have caused the roof at Rocket Arena to be blown off.

Because of the injuries to Garland, Hunter, and Mobley someone has to step up. Excuses are for when the series is over. Competitors overcome them. And a couple of players are going to have to produce more if none of the injured players can go.

Atkinson has to figure out a way to have both players be serviceable offensively so their defense can be a weapon.

Really, what Sunday’s loss did most was make tonight’s game pretty much a must win for the Cavaliers. They’ve demonstrated all year the ability to win on the road, but losing both home games would make it very difficult to advance.

This might be the first time all season this groups back have been against the wall. We will see what the response is.

A Week Later, Taking Two QBs Is Still Puzzling

We still are puzzled by the Cleveland Browns’ draft and it is now over a week old.

We have been critical of the “collaborative process” that GM Andrew Berry always talks about because to us, there has to be a single person that sets the vision and philosophy of what Cleveland Browns football looks like.

And once again, the weirdness did not begin until late in day two.

Trading down to get Mason Graham? No problem there. We watched, like most people in Ohio, as Graham was a dominant figure in Michigan’s shocking win over the eventual National Champion Ohio State Buckeyes. Putting him next to Myles Garrett on the defensive line should pose a very strong front four for defensive coordinator Jim Schwarz.

UCLA LB Carson Schwesinger received some first round grades and could be a sign that Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah will not be ready to play this year.

We do not think Jerome Ford is an every down running back and actually have no problem drafting two. The running game is a staple of Kevin Stefanski’s offense, so taking Quinshon Judkins and Dylan Sampson remakes the running back room.

FYI, we would still bring back Nick Chubb. The worst-case scenario (besides another 3-14 record) for the Browns is Chubb going elsewhere and still have something left in the tank. It may not be the best football move, but it would be great for the fan base, which has seen its share of mediocre football recently.

Also, TE Harold Fannin Jr. is another solid choice, another staple of the Stefanski offense is having two quality tight ends.

Of course, we are really getting at taking two quarterbacks. And we bet if there was a singular person in charge when whoever came up with the idea to take Shadeur Sanders just 50 selections after taking Dylan Gabriel, the football czar would have said no.

We envision those Progressive Insurance commercials with “Dr. Rick” with the doctor sighing and shaking his head when the idea is brought to him.

First off, the Browns need a quarterback, but they also could use offensive line help, another wide receiver, another edge pass rusher, and in today’s NFL, you can always use a cornerback.

But how is the team going to keep four quarterbacks on the roster? If winning games is the goal, and it should be, despite many media members in town wanting to write off the 2025 season, then Joe Flacco should be the starter for Game 1.

They traded for Kenny Pickett prior to the draft, and he is a former starter in the NFL. And we said coming into the draft, even if the Browns took a passer with the second overall pick, we wouldn’t let him touch the field until late in the ’25 campaign. At the earliest.

The point is the Browns had a solid draft until they decided to take two QBs, one of whom might be the most famous player in the draft. And that’s not a rap on Sanders, who we would have taken earlier.

It’s having two rookies on the roster at a position where only one can play.

And worse, the Browns have created this circus themselves. Perhaps that what they want, just like the Dallas Cowboys always want to seem to be in the news. But does that help you win?

More than likely, Browns’ fans will find out it doesn’t. But at least, it will be a collaborative process from the front office.

Cavs Dominant Vs. The Heat, Pacers Will Be A Challenge

When you sweep a first round series outscoring your opponent by 122 points in the four games, that’s historic. But then you have to remember the Cavaliers won 27 more games than the Miami Heat during the regular season.

We thought the playoff tested Heat would provide a good challenge for the wine and gold, but the two games in Florida were a total beatdown and it is on to the Eastern Conference semi-finals against Indiana, who defeated the Milwaukee Bucks in five games in that matchup.

Despite what fans want in their hearts, which is a series against the Washington Wizards, the reality says the opponents in the playoffs get tougher as you move along. Indiana is no different.

The Pacers, who by the way went to the conference finals a year ago, got off to a tough start this season at 10-15. After that, they went 40-17, meaning they are a very good team, perhaps the third best in the East.

Rick Carlyle is a very good coach, winning a title with Dallas in the 2010-11 season, and has won over 1000 games as a head coach in the NBA.

Moreso, the Pacers are long, exactly the type of team the Cavaliers have had troubles with this season.

Indiana has size in the backcourt with Tyrese Haliburton (6’5″) and Andrew Nembhard (6’5″). As we know, that’s a big advantage over the Cleveland backcourt.

The Cavs match up pretty well in the frontcourt, as the Pacers go with Aaron Nesmith (6’5″), Pascal Siakam (6’8″), and Myles Turner (6’11”). Their sixth man is Bennedict Mathurin at 6’6″, and Obi Toppin (a player we’ve wanted the Cavs to sign) also gets a lot of minutes and he’s 6’9″.

They also have a solid back up point guard that Cleveland fans will hate in T. J. McConnell, who was a big factor in Indiana’s playoff run a year ago.

They like to play with pace, just like the Cavs, so it should be an action-packed series.

Both teams can make three-point shots, the Cavaliers were second in the NBA making 38.3% from beyond the arc, while the Pacers knock down 36.8%, good for 9th in the league.

Both teams take care of the basketball, among the top five in the NBA in least number of turnovers. They both shoot well overall, ranking in the top three in overall shooting percentage.

Considering this is a 1-4 matchup, these teams are very, very similar, and that leads to a very good matchup.

We still think the biggest edges the Cavs have are Evan Mobley and De’Andre Hunter. Mobley will likely play Siakam, who averaged 20.2 points per game. And after a rough first game against Miami, Hunter wound up knocking down 8 of 13 from three and averaged 17.3 points per game in the last three contests.

And remember that Darius Garland didn’t even play the last two games against the Heat.

One thing that would help the Cavs is getting more out of Dean Wade, who played 52 minutes in the series and took just five shots, making two. Wade played solid defense, as he always does, but he has to contribute something offensively as the opponents get better.

It would not be a shock to see Carlyle play off him and double up on a better offensive player.

And remember, the Pacers played a short-handed Milwaukee squad in round one. Cleveland is not that.

It should be very good basketball being played in this series. The Cavs should be able to advance to the conference finals though.

First Check In For The Guardians

The Cleveland Guardians completed one sixth of their schedule over the weekend, playing game #27 in a dismal 12-3 loss to the Boston Red Sox. The Guards finished this portion of the slate at 15-12, a pace where they would end the year at 90-72, which would likely get them into the post-season.

Cleveland is 8th in the American League in runs scored, averaging 3.95 runs per game, a little below the 4.05 which is league average. Their OPS is at 694, slightly above the AL mark of 691.

All in all, the offense is average, about where it was when the 2024 season concluded.

The pitching staff has been an issue, with a staff ERA of 4.37, 12th in the junior circuit. The Cleveland hurlers have allowed the 5th most walks in the AL, and Tanner Bibee and Luis Ortiz both rank in the top ten in the league in issuing free passes.

And Guardians’ pitchers have also had problems keeping the ball in the yard, as they are tied for 3rd in allowing the most home runs. Giving opponents walks and allowing home runs in Exhibit A in giving up a lot of runs.

What has been particularly disappointing about this edition of the Guardians to date has been the defense. This organization has prided itself in this area, even overpaying for gloves in the recent past.

Brayan Rocchio, a finalist for a Gold Glove a year ago has made six errors and seemingly misplays one routine play per game. We understand gloves go into slumps as well, but the club needs Rocchio to come out of it. The usually reliable Jose Ramirez has also made four errors and has other misplays that haven’t shown up in the box score.

So, it’s not losing Andres Gimenez, okay!

Rocchio is clearly the best defensive shortstop the Guardians have, so they need him to start making the routine plays. We do wonder if the consistent shuffling players around to different positions on pretty much a daily basis hurts the overall defense though.

We doubt that is going to change though.

Back to the pitching, there is no question the team needs Bibee and Gavin Williams to pitch better. Both have been very inconsistent, although for the latter, that has been the norm in his career. Ortiz has to throw more strikes. In his two worst outings of the season, he’s walked four (in 4.2 innings) and five (4.1 frames).

When he throws strikes, he can be very effective.

The bullpen has been in a bit of flux because of Emmanuel Clase’s struggles, allowing 20 hits in 11.1 IP. He looked better in an outing on Saturday, so perhaps he’s turned a corner.

Cade Smith, Hunter Gaddis, and Tim Herrin have mostly been good, but we wonder how much of a burden they can continue to carry, especially after last season.

Offensively, it’s still the same story, but with a different name. Last year, it was about Ramirez, Steven Kwan, and Josh Naylor. Kyle Manzardo is off to a solid start, with an 840 OPS and team leading totals of 7 HR and 18 RBI. Unfortunately, the Guards dealt Naylor, so the offense still has just three solid bats.

Angel Martinez has provided a lift with a .365 OBP, but that’s based on hitting .360. He and Kwan are the only players with an OBP of .350 or higher.

They do have some pop as five players have slugging percentages over .450. Gabriel Arias has provided nine extra base hits, and a solid .272 batting average. His defense at 2B has been very good as well.

Considering the holes, Steven Vogt’s team is off to a solid start. No one can complain about 15-12 at this point. The starting pitching still needs to be better, meaning more consistent, and providing more outs.

A Logical Browns’ Draft Goes Weird

We always say the easiest thing for an executive of a professional sports franchise can do is either start a rebuild by trading off valuable commodities for future pieces (draft picks or prospects).

The second easiest is to play for a year or two down the road. We always criticize the Cleveland Browns for their seemingly forever “free beer tomorrow” attitude, but it’s hard to criticize most of what they’ve done in this year’s NFL Draft.

When Jacksonville threw in a first round draft pick in 2026 to move up three spots and take the second overall selection, it became a no brainer for GM Andrew Berry.

Our guess is even though Berry talked about Travis Hunter in glowing terms at a press conference, he and the organization wasn’t in love with the player or with Abdul Carter, so they traded down to get another early second round selection and the additional first.

No doubt all Browns’ fans will be rooting against the Jaguars from day one of the ’25 season.

We thought Mason Graham at worst would be a quality defensive tackle in the NFL so we had no problem with that choice. With Graham and second year DT Mike Hall along with Myles Garrett, but defensive line should be solid for years to come.

Eyebrows were raised by taking LB Chase Schwesinger out of UCLA because the Browns usually ignore the position. But there was buzz about him going late in the first round and reports say he’s a tackling machine. It’s not as though the Browns don’t have a need there.

We aren’t enamored by Jerome Ford as the lead back for the Browns, so selecting Quinshon Judkins out of Ohio State at #36 makes sense. Our bet is he will be the primary runner for Cleveland this season. And they added Dylan Sampson from Tennessee in the fourth round.

Remember, Kevin Stefanski likes to run the football, so the more quality runners the better.

The Browns play a lot of two tight end sets, so have a pair who need to be respected in the passing game also seems good. Harold Fannin from Bowling Green is a solid pass catcher who can team with David Njoku in “12” personnel.

We wanted the Browns to draft a QB, so first they took Dillon Gabriel who is maybe 5’11” and didn’t seem to be the best passer on the board. And guys like Shadeur Sanders, Quinn Ewers, and Will Howard were still available.

And then they took Sanders in the fifth round. Sanders is without question the better prospect behind center, so now what do the Browns do with two rookies at QB? Besides, it’s not as though Cleveland doesn’t have other needs. They could’ve used an edge rusher, an offensive lineman, a safety, to bolster positions in which they need help.

What looked like a sound reasonable draft turned into a “what the heck are they doing” draft. There was certainly no reason to take two QBs, if they wanted Sanders, they could have taken him when they took Gabriel.

It’s not a rap on Gabriel, it simply makes no sense to take both.

We heard a radio talker discussing the first overall pick for the Browns in 2026. If they have it, it better be because Jacksonville went 2-15. No matter what happened in this draft, the Browns can’t go 3-14 again.

Someway, somehow, they need to win football games. It might be like 2023, when they leaned on the defense to do it.

A Big Night For Browns And The Thought Partners

The biggest question following tonight’s NFL Draft should be what will sports talk radio and all of the podcasts which discuss the Cleveland Browns talk about after this weekend?

Yes, we are sure if the Browns don’t move up tonight using the 33rd overall selection, there will be ad nauseum discussion tomorrow and who they should take or who should they trade for with that pick, but we are really talking about Monday. What do they fill airtime with?

This could be and probably should be a pivotal moment for both the franchise and the front office. This regime started with a bang, going 11-5 in Kevin Stefanski’s first year and with what looked like a solution to their quarterback issues in second year pro Baker Mayfield.

That was followed by an 8-9 season in which Mayfield play hurt and the organization either soured on him or got distracted by a shiny object in Deshaun Watson.

Owner Jimmy Haslam called what happened in the off-season following that year “a big swing and miss”. They traded the future of the franchise, one that was showing signs of finally having “good bones” for Watson. The price was three first-round draft picks, among other things.

That limited how the front office could continue to add talent and patch up holes to a pretty talented roster for three years.

Somehow, the Browns made the playoffs in Watson’s second season, although it was without help from the player who they ruined their future for. That team made the post-season with an incredible defense and a late season offensive surge led by free agent signee Joe Flacco.

The Browns let him go after he played very well for them. Can you say, “self-sabotage”?

It wasn’t the only weird move by the front office after a pretty good season. They fired several offensive coaches, including coordinator Scott Van Pelt. It seemed the goal of the front office was no longer winning; it was making the Watson decision look like a good one.

That should never be the goal.

So, this front office needs a good weekend. We don’t want to go back to change general managers and/or head coaches every year days. We felt at times during those days that maybe things could have clicked if change wasn’t a constant.

Perhaps Mike Pettine could have done better without front office interference or Eric Mangini could have been a better coach if he were not also a terrible GM.

But now, it doesn’t seem like anyone is accountable. And they should be. The Browns’ front office mangled a five-year period if which they had solid talent. They came out of it with two playoff appearances and one post-season win.

This group has a chance to restock the cupboards and put the team back on a winning track. And that needs to start next season. Haslam, Paul DePodesta, Andrew Berry, and Kevin Stefanski made this bed.

They need to have success in 2025, and by that we mean, be in contention for a playoff spot after they’ve played ten games. It’s not a huge ask, right?

That path starts tonight. Don’t overthink it, don’t look at three to four years from now.

As Al Davis used to say, “Just win, baby”!

Guards Need To Get Clase Back To Being Clase

We are sure many Cleveland Guardians’ fans are concerned about Emmanuel Clase’s struggles to begin the season. He has made 11 appearances to date in 2025, and probably the most concerning statistic is he has allowed 20 hits in 10.1 innings.

Look, every closer has stretches where things aren’t clicking. We went back to 2007, when the Yankees’ closer started the year with four straight scoreless appearances. The rest of the month, the great Mariano Rivera pitched five times.

In those five games, he pitched 3.2 frames and allowed 10 hits and nine runs, striking out four and walking two. He allowed just one homer. After that stretch, Rivera allowed 16 runs the rest of the season, finishing with a 3.15 ERA and 30 saves.

We aren’t concerned about the All-Star closer, mostly because he is still throwing around 100 MPH. However, we aren’t sure Steven Vogt should bring him into a one run game in the ninth for his next appearance. We’d use him in a lower leverage situation the next couple of times out.

It doesn’t mean we are running away from Clase, nor does it mean we advocated trading him. One of the complaints about the man who has led the American League in saves each of the last three years is he doesn’t strikeout a lot of hitters despite his ungodly stuff.

The last two seasons, he has fanned less batters than innings pitched, and in the two years prior, he fanned five more than his inning total in those years.

One popular theory is that hitters swing early in the count and take their chance because if Clase gets ahead 0-2 or 1-2, his stuff is so electric, batters have no chance. That seems plausible to us.

On the other hand, when the ball is put into play, there is a chance for a base hit to happen. But what doesn’t usually occur to Clase is giving up home runs. In his career, totaling 329 appearances and 323 innings, the right-hander has allowed only 14 homers.

To put that in perspective, Tanner Bibee has allowed seven dingers. This year!

It appears this year that many of Clase’s deliveries are winding up in the middle of the plate, and 100 MPH or not, hitters are going to put solid swings on pitches right down the middle.

The great thing for Steven Vogt is he has options to close games. We are sure both Cade Smith and/or Hunter Gaddis can close until Clase gets his location better. And Paul Sewald has 85 career saves. We would imagine the Guardians’ pitching coaches can find something relatively quick.

Unfortunately, using those pitchers as closers opens up a slot in the bullpen.

For a team like the Guardians, these games in April and May are just as important as the ones down the stretch. Every game you can put in the win column is important, so if you have the lead after eight innings, you have to put it away.

Guardians’ fans have been spoiled by Emmanuel Clase. He’s been so good for four years, three of those seasons with an ERA of under 2.00. And it is important for the staff to get him back to where he has been since arriving in Cleveland.

Heat Provide A Solid Challenge For Cavs In Round One

The Cleveland Cavaliers had to wait to find out who their opponent would be when they host the first round of the NBA Playoffs, and they will find they are about to get an early lesson about playoff intensity.

The Miami Heat will open the series tonight at Rocket Arena and will be making their sixth consecutive playoff appearance. Yes, they lost in the first-round last season but made the Finals the year prior and in 2019-20, and went to the conference finals in 2021-22.

This is not to say the Cavs won’t win the series, because they should, but the Heat have been there before and have perhaps the best coach in the league in Erik Spoelstra.

Miami is a solid defensive team, ranking 9th in defensive efficiency, but their offense is only 21st. The Cavaliers are actually the better defensive squad, ranking 8th. However, they had the best offense in the NBA this year.

They are led by the physical Bam Adebayo, who has played 74 playoff games in his career, and sharpshooter Tyler Herro, who averaged 23.9 points per game. They added former Cavaliers’ first overall pick Andrew Wiggins in the trade for Jimmy Butler and got defensive stalwart Davion Mitchell in the same transaction.

And rookie Kal’El Ware can be a force inside the paint as a good defender and shot blocker.

This will be a good test for Kenny Atkinson’s Cavaliers because we would expect the Heat to play very physical which is probably the biggest worry fans and experts have about Cleveland. How will they stand up against a physical team?

Davion Mitchell’s presence on the floor could pose problems for Darius Garland and Donovan Mitchell, more so the former. Garland has had issues against physical defenders in earlier playoff appearances, and he will be presented with this challenge right off the rip.

Spoelstra is known for doing some different things to take advantage of the opponents’ weaknesses, but we feel the Cavs are in a better position with Atkinson to counter those moves. No rap against J.B. Bickerstaff, who did a marvelous job with the Pistons this season, but in our opinion, he was slow to adjust at times to what the opposition was doing.

Besides, the wine and gold offense is pretty diverse. Like a lot of NBA teams, it is not primarily pick and roll oriented. Atkinson made Evan Mobley and Jarrett Allen playing together effectively on offense by using player movement.

Cleveland does a lot of big-to-big passing, and a lot of flex cuts off the ball to get lay ups with the defense spread to guard the three-point shot, which the Cavs made at a 41.5% clip as a team.

They are deep too. We would expect Atkinson to stay with his nine or ten player rotation until someone forces their way out of playing time, either offensively or defensively.

The Cavs have been on cruise control for pretty much the last three weeks or so, but we anticipate them being ready right away tonight. They understand last season ended in disappointing fashion and they also realize they have a chance to put another banner up in Rocket Arena.

We think it is a good tone setter to play a team with the Heat’s pedigree right off the bat. The Heat was good defensively, but the Cavs have more weapons on offense. The series will be challenging but that good.

No better time to get in playoff mode than the first series.

Call Us Names, But Talking Baseball Is Tough Now

We love baseball. It has been our favorite sport as long as we can remember. And one of the reasons are the statistics. As broadcaster Bob Costas has always said, those stats are part of the game.

Everyone knows “714” is the number of home runs Babe Ruth hit. The same with “755” which is Hank Aaron’s total. Pete Rose had 4256 hits, Cy Young 511 wins. These numbers have become part of the sport.

However, today the numbers seem to have become “exit velocity”, “horizontal break”, “hard hit rate”. All of them are interesting numbers and certainly can add some context to how a player may perform. However, none of them have any influence on winning or losing.

And as long as they are keeping score, that’s what the game is all about.

We are sure at least one person will refer to us as “get off my lawn” guy and a boomer but let us say that we were a voracious reader of Bill James’ Baseball Abstract when it came out, and it certainly changed the way we view the game.

A person currently on the radio in northeast Ohio once said the best use of analytics is as a justification for doing something, especially when it doesn’t work out. For example, asking a manager why he pinch hit a certain batter. It’s because he hits .382 vs. right-handers. The hitter might have popped up, but there was a reason for the decision.

That’s fair.

The hitting statistics do not take into account the number of times a hitter strikes out. For example, Hitter A, has an average exit velocity of 92.9 MPH and a hard hit rate of 50%, barreling the ball 13.7% of the time, currently 13th in baseball.

Hitter B’s average exit velo is 86.3 MPH, his hard-hit rate is 21.4% and the barrel rate is 2.9%.

Hitter A is Cal Raleigh of the Mariners, who is currently batting .203 (to be fair a 786 OPS) with 20 strikeouts in 73 plate appearances. The other is Steven Kwan, who is batting .333 with an 893 OPS and eight whiffs in 73 times at the dish.

So, when Raleigh hits it, he hits it hard a lot. The problem is he doesn’t make contact 27.3% of the time.

And yet, some people will tell me that Raleigh is a very good hitter, which he is, for a catcher, but there is a lot of swing and miss in his game.

As for the break on pitches, we sometimes wonder if a batter just stood there and didn’t swing, he might walk or at the least get ahead in the count. We see videos of ridiculous breaking action on pitches, but a lot of them don’t land in the strike zone.

There are people on social media thrilled that this information was put on the scoreboard at Progressive Field. Never have a watched a game and thought wow, how much did that break?

It’s fun to see after a game, but during? It doesn’t matter to us.

On Tuesday night, Bo Naylor was 0 for 1, with a walk, sacrifice fly, and sacrifice bunt. To us, he contributed to the offense. Games where a batter goes 0 for 4 and doesn’t walk? He has contributed nothing to the offense.

And hitters who do this on a regular basis are anchors in the batting order.

Look, these things are fun to look at for the newer fan. We get that, but let’s remember the game is about 27 outs and scoring more than the opponent. Simple numbers, correct?