Baker’s A System QB? How About He Has A Smart Coach.

We have said many times that sports commentators’ opinion on Baker Mayfield is based on what they thought of him prior to the 2019 NFL Draft.

If they liked the former Heisman Trophy winner then, they like him now, and if they didn’t like him, they find another reason for why the first overall pick in ’19 took the Browns to the playoffs last season.

Apparently, those people have a problem admitting they were wrong.

The latest discussion about Mayfield concerns whether or not he is a “franchise” quarterback or a “system” quarterback. We understand it’s summer and no football is going on right now, and the talking heads have to discuss something.

The criticism of Mayfield is that Browns’ coach Kevin Stefanski put him in this offense and that’s why Mayfield succeeded. Isn’t the epitome of coaching looking at a player and putting him in a position to get the most out of his talent?

Stefanski did what any good coach would do. He looked at Mayfield’s strength and weaknesses and did things to maximize the best things he does and didn’t ask him to do what he wasn’t capable of doing.

If that makes him a “system” quarterback, then so be it.

There is a difference between protecting a quarterback that has limited ability and having him make use of what he does well so he can perform better.

Often times, when a rookie quarterback comes into the game without experience, coaches have him dink and dunk down the field giving them safe, low risk passes. To us, that’s being a system quarterback, having the passer try to not lose the game, instead of winning it.

That’s not what Stefanski did with Mayfield. He is very accurate moving out of the pocket on bootleg rollouts, the game plan used those early in games to get him comfortable. We are sure Bill Belichick did the same thing with Tom Brady, and probably Paul Brown did the same thing with Otto Graham. It simply makes sense.

Mayfield takes hits for a lower than average completion percentage, ranking 30th in the NFL in that category in 2020, but really, the Browns’ offense doesn’t have him throwing a lot of short dump off throws to running backs, which would elevate that figure.

A couple of better things to look at is yards per completion, where Mayfield’s 11.7 figure ranks 7th in the league, a half yard behind Patrick Mahomes, and just ahead of Aaron Rodgers and Josh Allen.

Mayfield also ranks in the top five in completion percentage on deep throws, defined by traveling over 20 yards in the air. Wouldn’t you rather have that than a 70% completion rate on a bunch of short passes?

As for being a franchise quarterback? That’s based on results over time. As we have said previously, if the Browns go to the playoffs in 2021, he’ll ascend to most people’s top ten in the game lists.

If the Browns go to the conference championship game or dare we say, the Super Bowl, he’ll be a franchise quarterback. That’s how it works.

But don’t criticize him or any player for having coaches who have the sense to be good coaches and put players in positions to succeed.