Month: August 2010
Who Stays in 2011 for Tribe?
The Cleveland Indians are limping through this stretch of the season, and it is tough to watch. It is reminiscent of last September, when the Tribe went 7-25 from the beginning of the month through the end of the season.
Just think, they still have 35 games left!
In watching the games, I started thinking about whom currently playing for the team will definitely be here next season. And the answer is not that many are for sure. This doesn’t include guys like Grady Sizemore and Carlos Santana, who will likely be part of the 2011 Indians, but are currently not playing.
It also doesn’t account for off-season trades, although the players who would be in the for sure column are unlikely to be dealt by the current front office. It also doesn’t count players the Indians would like to be in next season’s lineup either.
That would leave SS Asdrubal Cabrera, RF Shin-Soo Choo, and DH Travis Hafner, and the latter is only in this category because of his untradable contract. If they are healthy, Sizemore and Santana will be starting on Opening Day 2011 too.
Matt LaPorta has struggled mightily since his salvo immediately after his call up, and should no longer be considered a sure thing at first base. His prolonged slump has caused his average to dip below .240.
Jason Donald has done some good things in his rookie campaign, but he has had problems defensively and hasn’t hit enough to be considered a lock. His OPS of 692 is below average, and with the plethora of candidates for 2B in the organization, such as Cord Phelps, Jason Kipnis, Josh Rodriguez, and holdover Luis Valbuena, he’s not guaranteed to start.
Third base is a mess, and it doesn’t seem like the team is going to take a look at Jared Goedart anytime soon. It wouldn’t be a surprise if Andy Marte and Jayson Nix weren’t in the organization come spring training. The same can be said about Shelley Duncan, who with extended playing time has shown the holes in his swing.
In the outfield, Michael Brantley’s recent performance gives him a leg up on a starting job, but it shouldn’t be etched in stone. If Brantley can hit, then it makes it easy to move Sizemore to LF to help take some pressure off his knee.
Trevor Crowe has the second most at bats on the team this year, which is an indictment of what type of team this is. However, he’s failed to take advantage of his opportunity. He’s a fourth outfielder, at best and certainly not a lock to make the team next year.
On the pitching side, the only for certain is Fausto Carmona. Mitch Talbot’s recent slide should put him in the candidate stage for next year, and Justin Masterson looks to be headed to the bullpen in 2011.
The other current starters, Jeanmar Gomez and Josh Tomlin, will be in the mix to open next year in the rotation, but certainly aren’t locks.
The bullpen is actually the most stable part of the team. Chris Perez will open 2011 as the closer, and Rafael Perez has rebounded from his horrible start to prove quite effective. Joe Smith is serviceable, and Tony Sipp will be back next year as well, although it would help if he could keep the ball in the park regularly.
The point is the organization isn’t taking advantage of their time out of contention. Yes, it’s understandable to show loyalty to guys like Duncan and Marte, but if they aren’t going to be here next season, then let’s look at Jordan Brown and Goedart. Maybe they will show something to impress the brass.
These guys can be called up in a week anyway, but just maybe they should have been in there already. Some of these will be on the roster to open the season in 2011, but that doesn’t mean they are major league players either.
The uncertainty for next year can’t be encouraging if you are a fan of the Cleveland Indians.
MW
Tribe Motto: Woe Is Us
The Cleveland Indians can drive you crazy. After playing well against contenders immediately following the All-Star break, they are playing with seemingly no purpose in losing 9 of 12 versus teams out of the race.
In the meantime, the front office (including the ownership) is busy patting themselves on the back because they spent over $9 million on draft picks taken in the June amateur draft. Isn’t that what a good “small market” franchise is supposed to do?
Since the odds of the team signing any major free agents are slim, the lifeblood of the organization must be in player development. That’s how the Minnesota Twins remain competitive. They keep adding good young players to their farm system and then they develop them.
That’s also the biggest reason the Tribe has floundered for much of the last ten years. Poor talent evaluation and poor draft picks usually mean a long period of time looking up at other teams in the standings.
Make no mistake, it’s better that the Indians spend money on the draft than not. However, fans get tired of the constant promotion when the franchise decides to pony up. They don’t care. They just want to see a winning team, a team they can be excited about. They don’t care how you get the talent, just as long as you get it.
The Dolan family and the front office seem to want to tell you when they do well, but they are offended by criticism when they don’t. This is the mentality that has to change on the corner of Ontario and Carnegie. Just get better and get competitive.
Stop talking about the pitfalls of being a smaller market team, and stop griping about how unfair the system is. Fans see plenty of examples of teams in similar size cities that are successful, there aren’t many, for sure, but the Twins, Reds, Rays, and Padres are having good seasons. Instead of moaning and complaining, just get to those teams level.
It seems like the Indian ownership would rather wallow in their mediocrity. Instead of complaining about the inadequacies of baseball, tell fans how you are going to combat it and win anyway. It’s possible. However, if all you focus on is that life is unfair, and then it becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Maybe the Dolans should adopt the philosophy of their manager, Manny Acta, who has been quoted as saying “life’s not fair, grab a batting helmet”.
There are even rumors that among the changes being made at Progressive Field next season is a reduction of suites, because the ownership doesn’t think the park can have more than 40,000 seats anymore.
Here’s a clue…get a better team and watch people buy tickets! There will be sports dollars available in this market over the next few years due to the departure of LeBron James. If the Indians can get back to the top of the AL Central Division, the fans will come back.
Right now, everything about this franchise is defeatist. That’s has to end. When Phil Savage made his infamous comment about the “woe is me” attitude in Cleveland, the Indians took this to heart.
Please Mark Cuban, call Larry and Paul Dolan and make them an offer. Baseball fans in this city will be forever grateful. They would like to be optimistic about the Cleveland Indians.
KM
Game 2 for Browns: OK
There goes the pre-season division championship for the Cleveland Browns. The dream of an undefeated exhibition season went out the window Saturday night in a 19-17 loss in the rain to the St. Louis Rams.
At this time of year, whether you win or lose doesn’t matter. However, the inability to hang on to the ball Saturday night was troubling, as it appeared the Browns never played in the rain before, particularly in the first quarter when it looked like the ball was a bar of soap.
Still, there were some good things happening for this football team.
First, outside of the first couple of snaps that Jake Delhomme mishandled, he and Seneca Wallace played well. There is no question that this year’s Browns will have better quarterback play than last season, although that is not setting the bar particularly high.
The two signal callers combined for 17 completions in 25 attempts for 194 yards, two touchdowns and one interception (by Wallace). Wallace also had a 16-yard run for a first down. The offense looked efficient and moved the ball well, although keep in mind the Rams won one game last season.
Peyton Hillis was impressive running and catching the ball. He runs hard, through tacklers instead of around them. He provides a physical, punishing runner. Jerome Harrison made a nice run after a catch late in the first half for 32 yards.
Josh Cribbs played one of his better games at receiver, catching six balls, including a nice grab for a touchdown from Wallace. Chansi Stuckey caught three passes on crossing routes, something missing from the attack last season. Benjamin Watson made a tremendous catch on his touchdown from Delhomme, and even Robert Royal caught a pass from Wallace for 25 yards.
The offensive line struggled a bit, but keep in mind, the team was without Tony Pashos, Shaun Lauvao, and Pork Chop Womack. This gave Scott Kooistra and Billy Yates, two experienced players, more time than they normally would have received.
Defensively, CB Eric Wright was tremendous in the first half, breaking up passes and making tackles. LB Chris Gocong had six tackles, one QB hit, and one pass defended. And first round pick Joe Haden showed his quickness closing on receivers.
However, while Stephen Jackson was in the game, he rushed for 20 yards on four carries, and starting QB A.J. Feeley completed five of six passes for 45 yards and a touchdown. The Rams marched right down the field early against the Cleveland first team defense. That’s disconcerting since this unit is supposed to be improved.
It is tough to gauge the performance of the defense because once Feeley injured his thumb in the first quarter and rookie Sam Bradford came in; the St. Louis offense reverted to the Stone Age in terms of creativity. It’s likely a good high school defense could have stopped what the Rams were trying to do.
The Rams gained just 172 total yards for the contest.
On offense, neither Colt McCoy nor Brett Ratliff looked good. McCoy was 0 of 2 passing, although he didn’t get a great deal of time to throw. Ratliff hit just one of four passes for 10 yards, and threw the game clinching interception trying to fit one in to tight coverage.
Up next is the critical third pre-season game against the Lions on Saturday. This is generally regarded as the dress rehearsal, with the starters likely playing at least three quarters. It will ease Eric Mangini’s mind if his team doesn’t turn it over five times this weekend.
JD
Growing Pains for Tribe
Hafner: At Look at Numbers
New Offense, New Players Looked Good
It is rare that both teams are happy about a last second game winning field goal, but that is the oddness of the NFL pre-season schedule. No one wants to play overtime in these meaningless games, so the Packers were probably thrilled that Phil Dawson made a 46-yard field goal to give the Browns a 27-24 win.
Imagine the sense of panic from both teams when Dawson tied the game with a little over a minute to go in the contest.
As we said over the weekend, the most important thing to look at in these games in individual performances, because a win or loss can depend on a bunch of guys who will not make the final roster.
Still, you have to be a little happy with the quarterback play from Jake Delhomme and Seneca Wallace in the first couple of series against the Packer defense. It is refreshing to see guys who can hit open receivers, and for the most part, make completions that did not depend on a tremendous catch by a receiver.
The offense looked like a professional one, an attack that could mix both the run and the pass, instead of succeeding despite the quarterback play. And both Mohammed Massaquoi and Brian Robiskie hauled in three catches, with the latter scoring on one.
The tight ends were utilized too. Ben Watson caught one ball good for 20 yards, and Evan Moore caught two for 24 yards. And Peyton Hillis was a factor in the passing game as well; making three catches, including one for 26 yards.
Jerome Harrison did well, rushing for 25 yards on seven carries, and scoring a touchdown, while James Davis, last year’s early camp sensation, gained 24 yards on six attempts.
On defense, T. J. Ward looked very impressive. Yes, he made mistakes in coverage and he couldn’t stop John Kuhn at the goal line on Green Bay’s second touchdown, but he made eight solo tackles, a few of them being in the open field. It was nice to see someone in the secondary actually bringing someone down.
Ward and first round draft choice Joe Haden got plenty of action because of the absence of CB Eric Wright, and both did alright in coverage. Packer QB Aaron Rodgers hit 12 of 13 passes during his time in the game for 139 yards, but he is one of the NFL’s best passers. What you want to see out of the two rookies is improvement going forward.
It was not like last year when the Packers ran all over the Cleveland defense. Green Bay averaged just 3.7 yards per carry with a long run of 15 yards.
Despite not using perhaps the NFL’s best, Josh Cribbs, in the return game, the Browns had success here too, averaging 26.5 yards per kickoff return, with Haden’s 34-yarder being the longest and Syndric Steptoe returned two punts for a 16.5 yard average. Steptoe did have a critical dropped pass late in the game, though.
And Phil Dawson made a 58-yard field goal to tie the game in the fourth quarter, showing he is in mid-season form.
So, the offense looked better, some new players contributed, and the Browns won. Two of those things are important. All in all, it’s a much better start than the team had last year after the first pre-season game.
JD
Don't Judge by the Score
Masterson Needs to Move to Relief
The Cleveland Indians are in a period of learning. Manny Acta and the front office are trying to find out who can play at the big league level and who can’t.
Here is a clue for the Tribe brass…Justin Masterson is not a starting pitcher.
This is not based on last night’s performance against the woeful Baltimore Orioles, who have been playing better under new manager Buck Showalter. No, this is based on Masterson’s body of work this season.
In the 21 starts the big right-hander has made against teams other than the Boston Red Sox this season, he is 2-11 with an ERA of 6.05. Hitters are batting .292 against him for the season. Left-handed hitters are batting .313 against Masterson with an OPS of 863.
That means every left-handed hitter that faces Masterson turns into Shin-Soo Choo.
This is not to say Masterson is a lost cause. He has a tremendous ground ball to fly ball ratio and he throws in the mid 90’s. He’s just not a starting pitcher. He’s more suited to being a set up man or down the road, maybe even a closer.
After last night’s game, Acta protected his starter by saying the defense failed him. Luis Valbuena booted a ball at third base to key a four run fourth for the Birds, and in the fifth, Acta felt 2B Jason Donald should have turned a double play which would have got Masterson out of the inning.
However, there is no defense for the hurler giving up several hits after the miscues. Sometimes, the pitcher has to pick up the guys behind him. Also, the skipper didn’t mention the incredible play SS Asdrubal Cabrera made on a ball hit off Masterson’s leg in the fourth. The Indians had no business getting an out on that play.
Acta said he sees in Masterson a pitcher with swing and miss capabilities. That’s true. The big righty leads the staff in strikeouts, and he and perhaps Fausto Carmona are the team’s only starters who have what you would call power arms. However, unlike Carmona, Masterson gives up more hits than innings pitched (158 in 133.1 IP), and if you walk four guys per nine innings, that’s a problem.
Mitch Talbot will likely return to the rotation this weekend against Seattle, and probably will replace David Huff in the rotation. Perhaps he should take Masterson’s spot so Acta can give Huff a few more looks. Or send Huff back to Columbus and put Masterson in the bullpen so Carlos Carrasco can get some starts at the big league level.
It’s not as though Masterson has earned his continued presence in the rotation. In fact, since coming over to Cleveland at the trade deadline last year, he is 5-18 with an ERA over five.
This is not meant to bury the pitcher acquired from Boston for Victor Martinez. However, it is time to give him a new role on the team. He’s made a year’s worth of starts (33) since coming to the Tribe, and you can count the times he’s pitched real well on both hands.
He simply doesn’t have the consistency to be a quality starter right now. And his success in Boston came mostly out of the bullpen.
Justin Masterson has the power arm this organization needs, but right now that arm would best serve the team in a relief role.
MW
Cavs Lineup Up in the Air
It has now been one month since “The Decision”, and Cavs’ owner Dan Gilbert has been quiet since his initial salvo regarding his former star player and the future of the franchise.
New Cavs’ GM Chris Grant has made a trade for G Ramon Sessions and C Ryan Hollins, giving up Delonte West’s buyout clause in return, and he has also signed free agent F Joey Graham as a free agent. Graham is a defensive minded frontcourt player, while Sessions should help in new coach Byron Scott’s up-tempo offense.
You have to wonder what season ticket holders are thinking about now since they had to pay their money way back in February.
Although Scott hasn’t issued any comments on his roster, it seems the only starter etched in stone is J.J. Hickson, who made big strides in his second year, and reportedly has been working on getting some range on his jump shot in the off-season.
Mo Williams will likely start at one of the guard spots, but it is not clear if he will be the starting point guard, or come off the bench like Dallas’ Jason Terry, while Sessions runs the team.
And who starts at the off guard spot? Will it be Anthony Parker or perhaps second year man Danny Green?
Will Scott bring both veteran big men Antawn Jamison and Anderson Varajao off the bench, or will one start with Hickson?
And, of course, who replaces LeBron James in the starting lineup at small forward?
That’s a lot of questions for a team that is supposed to win an NBA title before the Miami Heat.
This is not to criticize Gilbert for sending the letter, because it was how the majority of Cavalier fans felt at the time. Add in the fact that the owner spent a considerable amount of time and money in an attempt to make and keep James and his friends happy, and you can understand the vitriol that came from Gilbert.
Really, he was in a no-win situation. He is being criticized by many in the national media for not standing up to James and telling him his behavior and that of his “entourage” was unacceptable.
However, had he done that and James still would have left, those same people would have hammered Gilbert for not doing enough to keep the star player with the franchise. He was open for criticism no matter how he handled James.
It seems like this was all in place no matter what happened this season, or no matter what the Cavalier franchise did for James and his people. The three players in question got together and set this up years in advance, which is a huge problem for the league, right David Stern?
It’s a problem for Stern because however powerful of a commissioner he may be, he’s no longer in charge. The players are now running the NBA, setting up their own teams; competitive balance is out the window.
Now it’s up to Grant and Scott to start the process of remaking this team. Don’t forget, the wine and gold have a huge trade exemption they received in the transaction made to get #23 more cash to spit on the franchise. They have to use a least a part of it this year, or else they lose it.
With less than two months remaining until the start of training camp, it is interesting to see what course the Cleveland Cavaliers will take this season.
JK